Interview with Dr. Eric D. Weitz
::
::
Title
Interview with Dr. Eric D. Weitz
Contributor
Weitz, Eric D. ; Gashurov, Irene
Subject
Nineteen sixties; Harpur College; Alumni and alumnae
Date
2019-04-02
Rights
In Copyright
Identifier
Eric Weitz.mp3
Date Modified
2019-04-02
Is Part Of
Oral Histories from 60's Binghamton Alumni
Extent
53:49 minutes
UUID
d5a68c98-d53f-46ee-8a9f-bbe3723fad90
Transcription
Alumni Interviews
Interview with: Eric Weitz
Interviewed by: Irene Gashurov
Transcriber: Oral History Lab
Date of interview: 2 April 2019
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Start of Interview)
EW: 00:00
You want to hold it? I am Eric White, and I am sitting in Esca Restaurant in New York City.
IG: 00:10
And what are we doing?
EW: 00:11
Irine Gashurov is interviewing me as an alumnus of Harpur College, Binghamton University.
IG: 00:20
And what was your graduation year? When did it [inaudible]
EW: 00:24
I think my official graduation is 1974. Though I actually graduated in December 1973.
IG: 00:33
Okay. So, tell us a little bit; you mentioned that you grew up in Queens. Tell us a little bit about your background.
EW: 00:43
Grew up in Queens in Bayside and had a fine New York City public high school education. And when it came time to go to college, the family circumstances were such that it was either CUNY or SUNY, and I needed to get out of the house [laughs], so Binghamton was a top choice for me, and that is where I went.
IG: 01:12
So, tell us a little bit about your parents, and did your parents go to college? What did they do? What were their expectations?
EW: 01:21
Well, my parents were typical, you know, first-generation born Jewish immigrants. My grandparents all came from the Russian Empire before World War One. My father was the first in his family to go to college, and he graduated City College in 1940 was always a very-very proud City College alumnus. He was a CPA, worked till a few weeks before his 92nd, a few weeks before he died, a few days before his 92nd birthday. They grew up in the Bronx, Talon Parkway. We used to go up there every Sunday when I was little. I was the youngest of three sons. One of my-my oldest brothers went to Cornell, so I guess we had an affinity for heading upstate.
IG: 02:23
So, what were you mentioned? This is your reasons for choosing Binghamton Harpur College were chiefly economic. But why did you? That was a SUNY school. Why did you choose Harpur rather than Albany? Or
EW: 02:39
Well, this will segue into the (19)60s and (19)70s. I was part of- I have an unusual political background, an unusual political background, in the sense that I had gone to a left-wing summer camp from the age of eight, and there were about half a dozen of these in New York State. The one I went to was Camp Hurley, outside of Kingston and near Woodstock, and the camp was then taken over by another left-wing summer camp and community center, Twin Link, in 1968, and that was operated out of a community center in East New York, Brooklyn. So, one of the reasons to go to Binghamton, and I frankly cannot remember if I had also applied to Buffalo, and I think I had applied to New Paltz, but I-I cannot quite remember. But one of the reasons to go to Binghamton is that some other members of this community center were already studying at Binghamton, and we wanted to build a group that would be active politically. So, we never had a big group. There were about eight of us, I think, maybe 10, probably eight. But that-that was the key reason that I was very active in this community center in Brooklyn and in the summer camp, where, when I got older, I also worked as a cook's helper and then as a cook from 1970 to (19)74.
IG: 04:42
So, what are some of the causes that you advocated through the distribution?
EW: 04:46
This is a long story, so that you might not have heard of yet. So, this community center. Remember, this is the era of the Black Power, when which became very divisive, and this community in summer camp continually advocated a politics of integration, as we called it then. It was very class-oriented. East New York, Brooklyn, was an interracial working-class community in those days. [crosstalk] Oh, really? Where-where were you born? In-in the public housing.
IG: 05:30
My parents were new immigrants.
EW: 05:32
Uh huh. Okay. So, we continually advocated for, as we said in those days, black-white unity, or sometimes we would say black-brown-white unity, but mostly it was black-white. And when I got to Binghamton in 1970, and again, this is the height of the Black Power movement, there were separate dorms for Black students, so we demanded that that separate dorm, or at least separate floors, excuse me, in the dorm, be dismantled, and we were perceived as attacking the black students in general. I would not, you know, on reflection, I do not think this was the smartest politics in the world. But those were the politics we pursued in 1970, and it became quite explosive, actually. There were huge mass rallies where we were attacked. One moment when a couple of us were beaten up a little bit by a couple of black students, though we had black students in our group, and the black students among us came under immense pressure from the other black students on campus.
IG: 07:09
So, what was their rationale for attacking you? What was the
EW: 07:13
that I am just going to express it? Their rationale was their belief that we were interfering with their desire for black separatism, black self-determination, black empowerment, and they claimed that the black students in our very small group were being manipulated after an altercation where some of us, including me, got hit. I mean, not badly, but got punched. I got punched in the face.
IG: 07:51
When did this happen?
EW: 07:53
This was probably fall 1970. Some of our people from the community center came up to support us, and that threw the larger group of Black and Puerto Rican students on campus into total confusion, because our community center was very integrated. It had Black staff members, Black volunteers, Puerto Rican staff members. So, you know, they started looking at us. They, Black Student Union, as sort of the official political representation of Black students, looking at us quizzically and not quite understanding who we were and what we were doing. So, unlike virtually everybody else in the student movement in those days at Binghamton and all around the country, we were anchored in a working-class community, and the leadership of this organization were trade unionists, ex-communists, so we kind of represented an old left tradition that nobody else had in the student movement of those days. So, we then also managed to get a meeting with Kenneth Clark. Kenneth Clark was, you know, a major mid-century African-American psychologist. His testimony was critical in the Brown versus Board of Ed decision. Kenneth Clarke served on the board of the New York State Board of Regents, and we held a meet. We had a meeting with him. He agreed to meet with us in New York City, and he then took the issue, I guess, to the rest of the Board of Regents, and the Board of Regents then declared that the separatist floors or dorms were illegal on SUNY campuses. So, in a sense, we won. But yeah, looking back, it is not what I thought at the time. Looking back, it was somewhat of a pyrrhic victory because I think we were Inflammatory and, well, inflamed the-the racial situation on campus more than we should have.
IG: 10:33
When did you come to that realization?
EW: 10:35
Oh, 10 years later. Yeah, 10, 10 years later. But the but the-the good thing we did I do not know if it is following your questions but the next year then we organized on SUNY and CUNY campuses for free tuition. Now obviously we lost, and I cannot remember if this was just before or just after tuition was imposed at CUNY. SUNY already had tuition, but this was the first, and maybe was the only time we organized a student movement that united CUNY and SUNY, and we had some very important rallies. We had a big lobbying day in Washington. It was very exciting. Unlike the anti-separatist dorms, this was an issue around which all sorts of students could unite. Of course, we lost, and after a year, the movement kind of petered out. But you know, I still think of that as a good thing. What we tried to accomplish. We had-I remember at the big meeting. You know, we had SUNY students from all over. We had students from Hostos Community College, from CCNY. That was quite something, and that was, you know, a genuine, you know, we would say today, diverse. In those days, we would say integrated or interracial movement, yeah. Again, amid the-the strong influence of black separatism, of Puerto Rican separatism in those days, and then the early 1970s in New York.
IG: 12:36
So, you had, I mean, really were experiencing sort of you were on the vanguard of social dynamics, social change from a pretty early age.
EW: 12:47
Yeah, this is how I grew up.
IG: 12:48
This is how you grew up. And how did your parents pursue?
EW: 12:52
They were horrified. [laughs] They were horrified. You know, they just wanted me to get an education and have a fine profession and get married. So, and then of course there was the anti-war movement that we also organized around. And at Binghamton, it was the-the Trotsky students, the Young Socialist League. That is the right name that was in the lead at organizing against the Vietnam War, but we were involved as well, and we would organize buses to Washington for the various anti-war rallies or to New York for the various anti-war rallies.
IG: 13:42
Tell us a little bit about the New York anti-war rallies that you participated in. Give us, you know, one-one snapshot.
EW: 13:50
Okay, this is a very personal snapshot. 1960. Well, this is before I was at Binghamton. So, 1967, I was a high school kid in New York, and it was a rallying demonstration that ended up at the UN. And somehow, to this day, I do not know how, I ended up very close to the podium, and I saw Martin Luther King, Stokely Carmichael, Floyd McKissick, other luminaries of the civil rights movement, and this connects to my academic research and writing because I remember Stokely Carmichael with all his great rhetorical power. I remember seeing him and hearing him say, and there on the 38th, think 38th floor of the United Nations, sits that Uncle Tom Ralph Bunche. Ralph Bunche was a major, you know, leading UN official for 30 years. One of the iconic photos of the Selma March has Ralph Bunche in the front with Parades Scott King and Martin Luther King. Ralph Bunche had worked for decades for civil rights in America, for human rights internationally, but in the heated context of the late (19)60s and early (19)70s, he was castigated as Uncle Tom by Stokely Carmichael and others. But those-those rallies were all those anti-war rallies were very important. I mean, there were 1000s upon 1000s of people. I remember marching down Central Park West, marching down Fifth Avenue, wherever we had permits, in the Sheep Meadow in New York before the United Nations. We also studied. We also studied. I am not sure what, but we did.
IG: 15:56
I was about to ask you. So how did you know? How did your academics, you know, how were they tied to your activism, or were they?
EW: 16:07
They very much were, because I went [coughs] excuse me, I went to Binghamton intending to study history and to go on for a PhD in history. There are no idea what that meant, and I initially went thinking I would specialize in Russian and Soviet history because of the Russian Revolution, the history of communism. I took Russian history courses. I started out, as I had mentioned to you, taking Russian language courses.
IG: 16:45
I am just curious, what was the Russian department's language?
EW: 16:49
I took. I remember it was small. The Russian department, the Russian language instructor, whom I think was a professor, was, I think, very good. I do not recall his name. What I do recall very-very clearly is the two-semester Russian literature and translation course that I took with someone. I do not know where or why he got to Binghamton. I think he came from Oxford. He had all the mannerisms of an Oxford don. I really, I do not recall his name. I do not know how he ended up in Binghamton, but these were two phenomenal classes that I took, and we read more than the standard Dostoy- Dostoevsky [Fyodor Dostoevsky]. We read Lermontov [Mikhail Lermontov] and Saltikovsky Mikhail Saltykov-Shchedrin and Chernyshevsky [Nikolay Chernyshevsky], and I still draw in my teaching on my- the knowledge of Russian literature that I got in that two-semester sequence. That that was great.
IG: 18:02
It would be great if you recall his name.
EW: 18:05
Yeah, you know, I do not, I do not, I do not even have anything with a record of that. You would have to go back and look in the archive.
IG: 18:14
I think someone else, I am quite sure, talked about him.
EW: 18:17
And Russian history I took with Sidney Harcave, who was at the end of his career, but a significant figure in Russian history in the, in the United States. But then I also then I started taking German history with George Stein, who then for decades, was in academic administration as a vice president at Binghamton? I took his very- the very first time he taught his Third Reich course. I took it, and he-he inspired me than to go into German history, so that is why I unfortunately dropped Russian language. I should have stayed with it, but then I started German language, and he would. George Stein was my mentor in many ways.
IG: 19:18
Do you know that Russian and other Slavic languages, or Russian in the 19th century, fell under the academic discipline of Germany?
EW: 19:37
Yeah-yeah.
IG: 19:38
So, were these any of these professors immigrants from Eastern Europe?
EW: 19:46
George Stein emigrated as a four-year-old from Vienna when Vienna was occupied by the Nazis. I took American labor history with Mel Dubovsky, who sure came from a Jewish New York-I think New York-immigrant family. I mean, there were very, very few requirements when I started, which for me was great. I took lots and lots of history and literature, took the bare minimum of-of science and math that I needed to take, which I think was one or two courses or two courses in each, and I just took lots of history and literature and loved it, and got a terrific liberal arts education. I mean, I only realized that later, of course, but I always have a fondness for Binghamton because of the excellent liberal arts education I received.
IG: 20:52
What were your fellow students like?
EW: 20:56
Well, in our small group, we were all very similar. We were all driven by politics and education. Those of us, you know, I mean, came from a lower- most of us came from a lower middle-class background. Well, some lower middle-class, working-class background. You know, for those like myself of a lower middle-class background, Jewish background, it was, you know, always expected we would go to college. Yeah, just single, please. [talking to the waiter] For those African American kids, more working-class backgrounds. It was more of a struggle for them, and they went into medical and technical fields, which, you know, fits in a lot of instances with kids from. Yeah, I know today from my CCNY students. Right. While others of us were more in the humanities.
IG: 22:09
How did you- did you feel, sort of, you know, this pervasive anxiety about the Vietnam War in your circle of friends?
EW: 22:18
Sure.
IG: 22:19
How did you talk about-
EW: 22:20
Like everybody else, like all-all the guys, we talk about it all the time. Now, I mean, I was fortunate. I- my student deferment held through college when the draft switched to a lottery system. I got a very high number, and then the war ended. But I would have I would have been drafted had the war not ended when it did. So, I was, I was lucky, and I do not know what I would have done. I mean, we talked all the time. In my group, we talk. You go in the army and organize against the war, which was-I do not know if I would have had the courage to do that. That was a dangerous path to go. We talked about going to Canada, or what? But I never had to face that because-because of being born in 1953 and having a student deferment that lasted till I graduated.
IG: 23:28
What was what were other you know signs of social change? In did you, for example, feminism was just beginning, right? And the feminist movement was beginning. Have you noticed that women were women students were treated any differently than the male students?
EW: 24:01
I cannot say I noticed, but that might have been a total blind spot.
IG: 24:04
Yeah.
EW: 24:05
, there certainly were a lot of women students. Thank you. Yeah, as I mentioned earlier, we were, you know, in many ways, we were shaped by an old left rather than a new left culture, and that meant that there was hostility toward a separate feminist movement, which, again, in retrospect, I think was ridiculous. But-
IG: 24:44
Explain that.
EW: 24:46
Well, I mean, a lot of the feminist politics in the late (19)60s and (19)70 s was for women to organize separately, whether it be in consciousness-raising groups or. Separate-separate organizations of women, and just as we oppose separate black and Puerto Rican organizations, we also oppose separate women's organizations. Although this community center really was terrific even before the emergence of feminism in raising expectations for women and opening paths for women into leadership roles, but it was kind of stuck in the 1930s and (19)40s mindset that of class politics are much more important than anything else. Anything about gender, and we did not even use the term. Anything about race. So, you know, we were a little bit cultish in that regard. And-
IG: 26:02
Do you think it could have been influenced by the fact that in the Soviet Union women were encouraged to pursue careers?
EW: 26:09
Yeah, I mean very much so.
IG: 26:11
Was shaped by embedded experience, or
EW: 26:15
Well, the old left was shaped by the experience. Even though you know the people I knew who were ex-communist, though they never ever talked about it because they had suffered in the McCarthy period, and you know they still bore the scars of the McCarthy period, and you know they still feared the impact on the organization if their communist past was revealed, and they had left the CPUSA, the Communist Party of the United States of America, either in the early (19)50s or some of them, and you know, finally in (19)56 with the Soviet invasion of Hungary, they still embodied and expressed much of this American Communist Party's culture and ideas of the 1930s and (19)40s. So, we were kind of a late, very late manifestation of that. Which, by the way, I did not really understand. I should. I do not know why I did not understand it, but I did not really understand it until I began my academic research, which my first book was a history of German communism from pre-beginnings in the 1890s to the collapse of the German Democratic Republic in 1990, and I had spent a semester and then a few weeks in the German Democratic Republic. So, I did not fully dawn on me that I had lived a late version of Communist Party culture until I was doing my own academic research. I probably should have realized it earlier, but for some reason it did not penetrate. I mean, again, that is the way our experience in this group was different from-from everyone else.
IG: 28:06
There were enough of you.
EW: 28:07
Yeah, there were about eight of us, so it was not that many.
IG: 28:10
Yeah.
EW: 28:10
And we were very tight, and we were very clannish in a way. Clannish, you know, the small stage.
IG: 28:17
What happened to the seven?
EW: 28:20
Well, we-we-we all graduated, and people went different ways. I had not seen most people for 30 years. I mean, I until last year, I went to a reunion. I mean, I-I moved around a lot, both for my own and my ex-wife's careers; moved around a whole lot. Though in the (19)70s, I was still in the late (19)70s until my ex-wife and I left New York in (19)83. I was still active in the community center in Brooklyn. But I think people who went through that organization, although probably all of us are very critical in retrospect, people went on to do very progressive things. A lot of people became teachers, teacher advocates, teacher trainees. A lot of people went into labor organization. I mean, one friend is runs. I think the labor education program for $11.99. Another friend ran labor education programs in Penn State. So, in that regard, People, [crosstalk] yeah, yeah, it definitely was. Even though people dissipated, and the community became very difficult, very rough. When I started going out to the community center. 1967 or thereabouts, and I lived in Bayside. It would take me two hours. I would go by bus and train all the way to Manhattan, all across Queens into Manhattan, and all the way out on the New Lots line to the second-to-last stop, Van Siclen Avenue, and you could do that. But then by 1970, it was actually too dangerous to walk even a few blocks from Van Siclen Avenue to the community center offices. The community center still exists, but it is more a social service agency than a community organizing place that it was in those days.
IG: 30:40
And I think that there is something poignant about being shaped by this rich culture that you did not know died out.
EW: 30:55
Yeah, right. Yeah, we were we were like the last lingering elements of it, which I think most of us did not quite realize at the time. I should have realized it because I was researching communism.
IG: 31:08
No, but it is more. I think it is more psychological.
EW: 31:12
Yeah, yeah.
IG: 31:15
So, how do you think your classmates would remember you during that time?
EW: 31:26
If any of them remember me, it would probably be as a member of this weird organization that was causing havoc on campus.
IG: 31:38
So, do you think that they would have looked upon you and that organization favorably, or just as something or?
EW: 31:46
Probably more strange than fad than favorably.
IG: 31:50
So did you, did you feel integrated into-
EW: 31:56
Campus?
IG: 31:57
Wider-wider milieu-
EW: 31:59
Campus? Yeah, yeah, sure. I did. I also played intramural football.
IG: 32:04
Okay, so tell us about that.
EW: 32:05
I played football in high school. I played intramural football. The only time I ever got hurt was playing intramural football. So, I had this kind of schizophrenic life in a way. But we also, I also hung out with these guys. I do not know whatever happened to them. I remembered very clearly. We had this table in the snack bar, and two guys were studying medieval history. I was studying Russian history. A couple, another guy, and we would sit at the table and read and talk, study and talk. So, I remember that fondly. I do not know what happened to any of them, and I do not remember their names. But yeah, I certainly felt integrated into the larger college.
IG: 33:00
Somebody said, you know, quite a number of people said that at Harpur College they feel that they receive the kind of education, undergraduate liberal arts education, that one would get at an elite private college.
EW: 33:18
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, I did not know that at the time. I had no experience in private colleges until I went to BU, which I disliked immensely. And then my first job was at St. Olaf College, and that was a totally different experience. That was my first experience of a small liberal arts college, and I had to tone down my New Yorkies there. That was because it is a Lutheran, also a Lutheran college. There was an immediate cultural clash with the students, so I had to learn-learn to be more estranged, and learn that irony, let alone sarcasm, does not work in the middle Midwest, especially at a Lutheran institution. But yeah, as I said, I mean, I-I still remember also my Litton Comp 101, which was taught by this renowned Joyce scholar. It was taught by two guys. Maybe both of them were renowned Joyce scholars. Cannot remember their names. But so, this had to have been fall 1970 when I started and took the mandatory lit and comp course. It was great. I loved it, and you know it served me well all my academic career. I drew on and still draw on things I read in Com. What I read in that two-semester Russian literature class; other literature classes I took. Yeah.
IG: 35:05
You were also in Germany. You lived in Germany and studied. So, what was that? When at what point did you?
EW: 35:13
Well, aside from, you know, traveling, backpacking, hitchhiking as a teenager, I went to Germany seriously in (19)79, (19)80 to do my dissertation research to West Germany. Yeah, that was a whole different experience. I mean, I was a naive American. My German was not very good then either. I-I could read, but my spoken German was not good. I mean, now it is fine. But I was studying the history of communism, labor history, and obviously there is, you know, the connection to my political activism in those days and what I was studying, and I was going to a center of labor history research in Bochum, in the Ruhr, Germany's one of Germany's major industrial regions, social democratic, in those days run state, North Rhine-Westphalia. I was just totally unprepared for the hierarchy and conservatism of West German academic culture. I was just
IG: 36:31
It is a carryover from the 19th century, indeed.
EW: 36:34
Indeed, a carryover from the 19th century, which you know has only been partially revised in this century, partially reformed in this century. So, I mean, I learned an immense amount. I did the dissertation research I had to do, and then I came back with an IREX grant, yeah, to East Germany in 1984 to do some postdoctoral research, and that was back.
IG: 37:12
When were you? Where were you then?
EW: 37:14
That was in Halle, in-in Prussian Saxony, as it was called Sachsen-Anhalt today, and that was the height of the German Democratic Republic, 1984. After that came the stagnation and decline, leading to the collapse in (19)89, (19)90. And by then, my wife and I had a baby, so we all went. It was very interesting. It was very interesting. Well, you know, in many-many ways. I mean, East Germans always looked to the West, to West Germany, as a point of comparison for consumer goods and all of that. And sure, the consumer goods were very, very limited, but you know, was not bad. I had no idea how extensive the network of spying was. You know, I had no idea until 1989, but nobody else did either. So, or at least nobody else outside. I mean, I was totally surprised when the wall came down about the extensiveness of the internal surveillance network. So, for example, we became very friendly with the secretary in the history department at the University Martin Luther University, Halle Wittenberg, and we had them over to our apartment in Halle in 1984, and they had us over to theirs, and I had no idea that they were actually running risks by doing that. Not until the collapse did it dawn on me that would become clear.
IG: 39:14
Do you know what happened to them after?
EW: 39:15
No, I lost contact with them. I saw them. I was back in early (19)89, in late August, early September (19)89, a few months before the wall came down. And as I often, when people ask me to predict something, I often say that you know, I then came, I came back from there, and I we had also become friendly with my advisor and his family, and I was there on my own at that time, and I went up with them to their dacha, as they always ironically called it in in the Harz Mountains. So, my advisor was, of course, a party member. Socialists, all university professors, were their friends. We were all party members, enterprise directors, physicians, and so. And I remember an evening with them, September 1989, and they were all totally depressed. They saw things changing in Poland and Czechoslovakia, and nothing happening in East Germany.
IG: 40:25
What year is this?
EW: 40:26
1989. So in October 1989, at Saint Olaf College, I told the class in German history, no less, that the wall would be with us for the rest of our lives. Four weeks later, the whole thing is gone. The whole thing is gone. So-so much for my predictive abilities.
IG: 40:45
Have you seen the Stasi installation at the Metropolitan Museum?
EW: 40:50
No. This is a Stasi installation at the Met, really.
IG: 40:53
Yeah.
EW: 40:54
Yeah. I mean, there was clearly a report on me in the what was called the Gault Office now because my advisor again we became very friendly and I did maintain contact with him and his family for many years. I have never looked to see it. One of these days I will, I expect, because he clearly had to file reports on me, so.
IG: 41:25
Well, it is interesting what-what files will be.
EW: 41:30
Well, they will all be available. They will all be available. Whatever-whatever is there will be available.
IG: 41:35
Congratulations very much about those files. It is about the bureaucracy of the Staffi headquarters and the nullity of its evil; you know, it is, it is very good. So, you know, what did you think? You know, just for the record, tell us a little bit about your career after Minnesota. Where did you? Where are you now? And what did you do? You have been at CCNNY for years.
EW: 42:16
Well, not that long. Since well-well, to-to-to run backwards a little bit from Binghamton, I went to Boston University, did my dissertation. My wife and I moved around a lot, too long to, too involved to-to relate all of that. Finished my dissertation (19)83. We were living in Southern Illinois because she is a physician. She had a public health service scholarship in Tufts, and she owed the feds two years' work in a what the feds called, at the time, a health manpower shortage area. She did a training in Mount Sinai, so we went from a Mount Sinai apartment on Park Avenue and 96th Street to a town of 5,000 people and 35 churches in rural Southern Illinois. I had never been west of Pittsburgh. I did not know what this was. I spent two years looking for a job. Did not find anything academic job, and then we moved to Minnesota for my ex-wife to do her training in hematology-oncology, and then I found a job at Saint Olaf College, where I was for 14 years, and then moved to the University of Minnesota in 1999, and faculty member there for 13 years, and then 2012 was recruited to City College of New York as the dean of humanities and arts with a mandate to build the humanities, which I was very-very happy to do so.
IG: 44:02
And you were a distinguished professor at CCNY and the University.
EW: 44:06
Yeah, yeah. I was I held two chairs at the University of Minnesota, an endowed chair endowed by an Armenian gentleman in Minneapolis, Arsham Ojanessian, that gave me that was devoted to issues of nationalism and human rights, within which there had to be attention to the Armenian genocide, and I had a distinguished McKnight University professorship at Minnesota, and then I came to CCNY and became a distinguished professor here as well.
IG: 44:46
So that is that is-
EW: 44:47
So.
IG: 44:48
You kind of shifted to human rights.
EW: 44:52
Well, I have for the last 15 years kind of tacked back and forth between German history and global history, and in particular the history of genocides and the history of human rights. So, my second book was a history of genocides in the 20th century.
IG: 45:15
That is fascinating. Is there a sort of a common cause for genocide, or is every genocide different?
EW: 45:24
Both things are true. Both-both points are true. I mean, there are certainly common patterns, and one of the very common patterns is an ideology and propaganda of exclusion. To put it in the most neutral and general terms, but it off but it often involves a rhetoric of debasement about the other, and the other is usually defined in national or racial terms, and that you can see as consistency, at least in 20th century, genocides running from the Herero and Nama of Namibia in the early part of the century through the Armenians, through Jews, the Holocaust, through Rwanda and Burundi.
IG: 46:17
Do you consider the Ukrainian famine a genocide?
EW: 46:20
I do not. I do not because if one follows the UN definition, the UN Convention of 1948, and scholars argue all the time about whether we should follow that convention or not, the issue of intent is primary in that convention, and I do not think Stalin's intent was to eliminate the Ukrainian population. I think it was the result of completely failed and inhumane development policies. I would say the same about Mao's Great Leap Forward, which killed them. Some of the estimates are that 40 million people died-died of famine- but I do not think there was an intent to eliminate the Ukrainian population as such.
IG: 47:12
Maybe a certain class of the Ukrainian population. I do not want to get into an argument.
EW: 47:18
Yeah, I know it is it is-
IG: 47:23
Yeah, because actually my family lived alongside the family because and-and you know all right well that
EW: 47:32
Maybe another time. I mean, one of my mentors, Norman Naymark, I am going to his retirement party next week at Stanford. I mean, he would argue that it was a genocide, and lots of people would. I do not see it, but-but it was, a it was a huge tragedy of that. There is no question.
IG: 47:58
So, so just continue. Is-is, you know, your career your-your books were on what you know what just give us the span of your writings.
EW: 48:09
So, the first book, as I mentioned, was a history of German communism from pre beginnings in the 1890s to the collapse of the German Democratic Republic. Then I wrote this book, A Century of genocide. The third book brought me back to German history, Weimar Germany: Promise and Tragedy, which, in terms of sales, has been the most successful of my books.
IG: 48:35
And what is the title of this book?
EW: 48:37
And the-the Weimar book?
IG: 48:40
Yes. In terms of sales, what is the name of the book?
EW: 48:43
Weimar Germany: Promise and Tragedy, and that gets used a lot in courses. And that-that book was a labor of love because that is what really got me involved in German history, the 1920s, the fact that Germany had the largest socialist and communist movements, all of the artistic, cultural, sexual experimentation of the 1920s. Most of my colleagues in German history and German studies come into the field via the Holocaust and the Third Reich. For me, it was really the 1920s, and I pushed the Nazis to the last chapter and argued that we should not read the triumph of the Third Reich back into the Weimar period, and should take the Weimar period on-on we should take the Weimar period on its own terms. And the-the next book, which will be out this September, is called A World Divided: The Global Struggle for Human Rights in the Age of Nation-states.
IG: 50:05
And what is that about?
EW: 50:05
And it is both an affirmative history of human rights is the best thing we have going for us, but also a critical history in the sense that it deals with the difficulties, the complexities, the always partial nature of human rights advances, and it is-it is a global history. It covers virtually every continent and specific cases drawn from virtually every continent since the late 18th century to the present. I have been working on that one for about 15 years.
IG: 50:37
15 years.
EW: 50:38
Yeah.
IG: 50:41
So, you know, we are wrapping up a little bit, and you know what I would like to ask is, for your wisdom at the conclusion of this interview, and for the young people who are listening, who will be listening to this interview, what-what do you think were the most important lessons that you have learned during your college years at Harpur College? What-what you know, kind of what words of-of wisdom can you learn?
EW: 51:18
For me, a liberal arts education-oops, sorry. For me, a liberal arts education with very few requirements was absolutely wonderful, and I do not know what the curriculum is like today, and I know in the sciences and engineering it is much more difficult, but I think college should be a time where, at least to some extent, you experiment, you branch out, you take things that sound interesting that you might not be good at or you might not be familiar with, that you open yourself up to literatures, other histories, other ways of knowing, other forms of inquiry. That is what college should be. College is not just training you for a job, and we actually we do that in the humanities very well, despite all the attacks the humanities have been under for years now in the United States, but the way you learn to think in the humanities and arts, the way you learn to research, to write in all of the various disciplines, sciences as well as the humanities, that is what is so important about college. Do not just stay within courses, disciplines you are comfortable with. Take advantage of all of the great faculty and all of the great offerings that exist, and also be aggressive about your education. That is what I tell my students at CCNY. Now we there is this complete obsession in this country with the elite universities, but it is the publics that educate 80 percent of American students, and you will not be as coddled in public universities, you might have to be a little more aggressive. You know, just be aggressive. Find the best professors. Find the best classes in whatever field there is, and go for it.
IG: 53:35
Thank you. That-that is great advice, and I thank you for an excellent interview, and it has been a pleasure.
EW: 53:44
It has been a pleasure for me.
(End of Interview)
Interview with: Eric Weitz
Interviewed by: Irene Gashurov
Transcriber: Oral History Lab
Date of interview: 2 April 2019
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Start of Interview)
EW: 00:00
You want to hold it? I am Eric White, and I am sitting in Esca Restaurant in New York City.
IG: 00:10
And what are we doing?
EW: 00:11
Irine Gashurov is interviewing me as an alumnus of Harpur College, Binghamton University.
IG: 00:20
And what was your graduation year? When did it [inaudible]
EW: 00:24
I think my official graduation is 1974. Though I actually graduated in December 1973.
IG: 00:33
Okay. So, tell us a little bit; you mentioned that you grew up in Queens. Tell us a little bit about your background.
EW: 00:43
Grew up in Queens in Bayside and had a fine New York City public high school education. And when it came time to go to college, the family circumstances were such that it was either CUNY or SUNY, and I needed to get out of the house [laughs], so Binghamton was a top choice for me, and that is where I went.
IG: 01:12
So, tell us a little bit about your parents, and did your parents go to college? What did they do? What were their expectations?
EW: 01:21
Well, my parents were typical, you know, first-generation born Jewish immigrants. My grandparents all came from the Russian Empire before World War One. My father was the first in his family to go to college, and he graduated City College in 1940 was always a very-very proud City College alumnus. He was a CPA, worked till a few weeks before his 92nd, a few weeks before he died, a few days before his 92nd birthday. They grew up in the Bronx, Talon Parkway. We used to go up there every Sunday when I was little. I was the youngest of three sons. One of my-my oldest brothers went to Cornell, so I guess we had an affinity for heading upstate.
IG: 02:23
So, what were you mentioned? This is your reasons for choosing Binghamton Harpur College were chiefly economic. But why did you? That was a SUNY school. Why did you choose Harpur rather than Albany? Or
EW: 02:39
Well, this will segue into the (19)60s and (19)70s. I was part of- I have an unusual political background, an unusual political background, in the sense that I had gone to a left-wing summer camp from the age of eight, and there were about half a dozen of these in New York State. The one I went to was Camp Hurley, outside of Kingston and near Woodstock, and the camp was then taken over by another left-wing summer camp and community center, Twin Link, in 1968, and that was operated out of a community center in East New York, Brooklyn. So, one of the reasons to go to Binghamton, and I frankly cannot remember if I had also applied to Buffalo, and I think I had applied to New Paltz, but I-I cannot quite remember. But one of the reasons to go to Binghamton is that some other members of this community center were already studying at Binghamton, and we wanted to build a group that would be active politically. So, we never had a big group. There were about eight of us, I think, maybe 10, probably eight. But that-that was the key reason that I was very active in this community center in Brooklyn and in the summer camp, where, when I got older, I also worked as a cook's helper and then as a cook from 1970 to (19)74.
IG: 04:42
So, what are some of the causes that you advocated through the distribution?
EW: 04:46
This is a long story, so that you might not have heard of yet. So, this community center. Remember, this is the era of the Black Power, when which became very divisive, and this community in summer camp continually advocated a politics of integration, as we called it then. It was very class-oriented. East New York, Brooklyn, was an interracial working-class community in those days. [crosstalk] Oh, really? Where-where were you born? In-in the public housing.
IG: 05:30
My parents were new immigrants.
EW: 05:32
Uh huh. Okay. So, we continually advocated for, as we said in those days, black-white unity, or sometimes we would say black-brown-white unity, but mostly it was black-white. And when I got to Binghamton in 1970, and again, this is the height of the Black Power movement, there were separate dorms for Black students, so we demanded that that separate dorm, or at least separate floors, excuse me, in the dorm, be dismantled, and we were perceived as attacking the black students in general. I would not, you know, on reflection, I do not think this was the smartest politics in the world. But those were the politics we pursued in 1970, and it became quite explosive, actually. There were huge mass rallies where we were attacked. One moment when a couple of us were beaten up a little bit by a couple of black students, though we had black students in our group, and the black students among us came under immense pressure from the other black students on campus.
IG: 07:09
So, what was their rationale for attacking you? What was the
EW: 07:13
that I am just going to express it? Their rationale was their belief that we were interfering with their desire for black separatism, black self-determination, black empowerment, and they claimed that the black students in our very small group were being manipulated after an altercation where some of us, including me, got hit. I mean, not badly, but got punched. I got punched in the face.
IG: 07:51
When did this happen?
EW: 07:53
This was probably fall 1970. Some of our people from the community center came up to support us, and that threw the larger group of Black and Puerto Rican students on campus into total confusion, because our community center was very integrated. It had Black staff members, Black volunteers, Puerto Rican staff members. So, you know, they started looking at us. They, Black Student Union, as sort of the official political representation of Black students, looking at us quizzically and not quite understanding who we were and what we were doing. So, unlike virtually everybody else in the student movement in those days at Binghamton and all around the country, we were anchored in a working-class community, and the leadership of this organization were trade unionists, ex-communists, so we kind of represented an old left tradition that nobody else had in the student movement of those days. So, we then also managed to get a meeting with Kenneth Clark. Kenneth Clark was, you know, a major mid-century African-American psychologist. His testimony was critical in the Brown versus Board of Ed decision. Kenneth Clarke served on the board of the New York State Board of Regents, and we held a meet. We had a meeting with him. He agreed to meet with us in New York City, and he then took the issue, I guess, to the rest of the Board of Regents, and the Board of Regents then declared that the separatist floors or dorms were illegal on SUNY campuses. So, in a sense, we won. But yeah, looking back, it is not what I thought at the time. Looking back, it was somewhat of a pyrrhic victory because I think we were Inflammatory and, well, inflamed the-the racial situation on campus more than we should have.
IG: 10:33
When did you come to that realization?
EW: 10:35
Oh, 10 years later. Yeah, 10, 10 years later. But the but the-the good thing we did I do not know if it is following your questions but the next year then we organized on SUNY and CUNY campuses for free tuition. Now obviously we lost, and I cannot remember if this was just before or just after tuition was imposed at CUNY. SUNY already had tuition, but this was the first, and maybe was the only time we organized a student movement that united CUNY and SUNY, and we had some very important rallies. We had a big lobbying day in Washington. It was very exciting. Unlike the anti-separatist dorms, this was an issue around which all sorts of students could unite. Of course, we lost, and after a year, the movement kind of petered out. But you know, I still think of that as a good thing. What we tried to accomplish. We had-I remember at the big meeting. You know, we had SUNY students from all over. We had students from Hostos Community College, from CCNY. That was quite something, and that was, you know, a genuine, you know, we would say today, diverse. In those days, we would say integrated or interracial movement, yeah. Again, amid the-the strong influence of black separatism, of Puerto Rican separatism in those days, and then the early 1970s in New York.
IG: 12:36
So, you had, I mean, really were experiencing sort of you were on the vanguard of social dynamics, social change from a pretty early age.
EW: 12:47
Yeah, this is how I grew up.
IG: 12:48
This is how you grew up. And how did your parents pursue?
EW: 12:52
They were horrified. [laughs] They were horrified. You know, they just wanted me to get an education and have a fine profession and get married. So, and then of course there was the anti-war movement that we also organized around. And at Binghamton, it was the-the Trotsky students, the Young Socialist League. That is the right name that was in the lead at organizing against the Vietnam War, but we were involved as well, and we would organize buses to Washington for the various anti-war rallies or to New York for the various anti-war rallies.
IG: 13:42
Tell us a little bit about the New York anti-war rallies that you participated in. Give us, you know, one-one snapshot.
EW: 13:50
Okay, this is a very personal snapshot. 1960. Well, this is before I was at Binghamton. So, 1967, I was a high school kid in New York, and it was a rallying demonstration that ended up at the UN. And somehow, to this day, I do not know how, I ended up very close to the podium, and I saw Martin Luther King, Stokely Carmichael, Floyd McKissick, other luminaries of the civil rights movement, and this connects to my academic research and writing because I remember Stokely Carmichael with all his great rhetorical power. I remember seeing him and hearing him say, and there on the 38th, think 38th floor of the United Nations, sits that Uncle Tom Ralph Bunche. Ralph Bunche was a major, you know, leading UN official for 30 years. One of the iconic photos of the Selma March has Ralph Bunche in the front with Parades Scott King and Martin Luther King. Ralph Bunche had worked for decades for civil rights in America, for human rights internationally, but in the heated context of the late (19)60s and early (19)70s, he was castigated as Uncle Tom by Stokely Carmichael and others. But those-those rallies were all those anti-war rallies were very important. I mean, there were 1000s upon 1000s of people. I remember marching down Central Park West, marching down Fifth Avenue, wherever we had permits, in the Sheep Meadow in New York before the United Nations. We also studied. We also studied. I am not sure what, but we did.
IG: 15:56
I was about to ask you. So how did you know? How did your academics, you know, how were they tied to your activism, or were they?
EW: 16:07
They very much were, because I went [coughs] excuse me, I went to Binghamton intending to study history and to go on for a PhD in history. There are no idea what that meant, and I initially went thinking I would specialize in Russian and Soviet history because of the Russian Revolution, the history of communism. I took Russian history courses. I started out, as I had mentioned to you, taking Russian language courses.
IG: 16:45
I am just curious, what was the Russian department's language?
EW: 16:49
I took. I remember it was small. The Russian department, the Russian language instructor, whom I think was a professor, was, I think, very good. I do not recall his name. What I do recall very-very clearly is the two-semester Russian literature and translation course that I took with someone. I do not know where or why he got to Binghamton. I think he came from Oxford. He had all the mannerisms of an Oxford don. I really, I do not recall his name. I do not know how he ended up in Binghamton, but these were two phenomenal classes that I took, and we read more than the standard Dostoy- Dostoevsky [Fyodor Dostoevsky]. We read Lermontov [Mikhail Lermontov] and Saltikovsky Mikhail Saltykov-Shchedrin and Chernyshevsky [Nikolay Chernyshevsky], and I still draw in my teaching on my- the knowledge of Russian literature that I got in that two-semester sequence. That that was great.
IG: 18:02
It would be great if you recall his name.
EW: 18:05
Yeah, you know, I do not, I do not, I do not even have anything with a record of that. You would have to go back and look in the archive.
IG: 18:14
I think someone else, I am quite sure, talked about him.
EW: 18:17
And Russian history I took with Sidney Harcave, who was at the end of his career, but a significant figure in Russian history in the, in the United States. But then I also then I started taking German history with George Stein, who then for decades, was in academic administration as a vice president at Binghamton? I took his very- the very first time he taught his Third Reich course. I took it, and he-he inspired me than to go into German history, so that is why I unfortunately dropped Russian language. I should have stayed with it, but then I started German language, and he would. George Stein was my mentor in many ways.
IG: 19:18
Do you know that Russian and other Slavic languages, or Russian in the 19th century, fell under the academic discipline of Germany?
EW: 19:37
Yeah-yeah.
IG: 19:38
So, were these any of these professors immigrants from Eastern Europe?
EW: 19:46
George Stein emigrated as a four-year-old from Vienna when Vienna was occupied by the Nazis. I took American labor history with Mel Dubovsky, who sure came from a Jewish New York-I think New York-immigrant family. I mean, there were very, very few requirements when I started, which for me was great. I took lots and lots of history and literature, took the bare minimum of-of science and math that I needed to take, which I think was one or two courses or two courses in each, and I just took lots of history and literature and loved it, and got a terrific liberal arts education. I mean, I only realized that later, of course, but I always have a fondness for Binghamton because of the excellent liberal arts education I received.
IG: 20:52
What were your fellow students like?
EW: 20:56
Well, in our small group, we were all very similar. We were all driven by politics and education. Those of us, you know, I mean, came from a lower- most of us came from a lower middle-class background. Well, some lower middle-class, working-class background. You know, for those like myself of a lower middle-class background, Jewish background, it was, you know, always expected we would go to college. Yeah, just single, please. [talking to the waiter] For those African American kids, more working-class backgrounds. It was more of a struggle for them, and they went into medical and technical fields, which, you know, fits in a lot of instances with kids from. Yeah, I know today from my CCNY students. Right. While others of us were more in the humanities.
IG: 22:09
How did you- did you feel, sort of, you know, this pervasive anxiety about the Vietnam War in your circle of friends?
EW: 22:18
Sure.
IG: 22:19
How did you talk about-
EW: 22:20
Like everybody else, like all-all the guys, we talk about it all the time. Now, I mean, I was fortunate. I- my student deferment held through college when the draft switched to a lottery system. I got a very high number, and then the war ended. But I would have I would have been drafted had the war not ended when it did. So, I was, I was lucky, and I do not know what I would have done. I mean, we talked all the time. In my group, we talk. You go in the army and organize against the war, which was-I do not know if I would have had the courage to do that. That was a dangerous path to go. We talked about going to Canada, or what? But I never had to face that because-because of being born in 1953 and having a student deferment that lasted till I graduated.
IG: 23:28
What was what were other you know signs of social change? In did you, for example, feminism was just beginning, right? And the feminist movement was beginning. Have you noticed that women were women students were treated any differently than the male students?
EW: 24:01
I cannot say I noticed, but that might have been a total blind spot.
IG: 24:04
Yeah.
EW: 24:05
, there certainly were a lot of women students. Thank you. Yeah, as I mentioned earlier, we were, you know, in many ways, we were shaped by an old left rather than a new left culture, and that meant that there was hostility toward a separate feminist movement, which, again, in retrospect, I think was ridiculous. But-
IG: 24:44
Explain that.
EW: 24:46
Well, I mean, a lot of the feminist politics in the late (19)60s and (19)70 s was for women to organize separately, whether it be in consciousness-raising groups or. Separate-separate organizations of women, and just as we oppose separate black and Puerto Rican organizations, we also oppose separate women's organizations. Although this community center really was terrific even before the emergence of feminism in raising expectations for women and opening paths for women into leadership roles, but it was kind of stuck in the 1930s and (19)40s mindset that of class politics are much more important than anything else. Anything about gender, and we did not even use the term. Anything about race. So, you know, we were a little bit cultish in that regard. And-
IG: 26:02
Do you think it could have been influenced by the fact that in the Soviet Union women were encouraged to pursue careers?
EW: 26:09
Yeah, I mean very much so.
IG: 26:11
Was shaped by embedded experience, or
EW: 26:15
Well, the old left was shaped by the experience. Even though you know the people I knew who were ex-communist, though they never ever talked about it because they had suffered in the McCarthy period, and you know they still bore the scars of the McCarthy period, and you know they still feared the impact on the organization if their communist past was revealed, and they had left the CPUSA, the Communist Party of the United States of America, either in the early (19)50s or some of them, and you know, finally in (19)56 with the Soviet invasion of Hungary, they still embodied and expressed much of this American Communist Party's culture and ideas of the 1930s and (19)40s. So, we were kind of a late, very late manifestation of that. Which, by the way, I did not really understand. I should. I do not know why I did not understand it, but I did not really understand it until I began my academic research, which my first book was a history of German communism from pre-beginnings in the 1890s to the collapse of the German Democratic Republic in 1990, and I had spent a semester and then a few weeks in the German Democratic Republic. So, I did not fully dawn on me that I had lived a late version of Communist Party culture until I was doing my own academic research. I probably should have realized it earlier, but for some reason it did not penetrate. I mean, again, that is the way our experience in this group was different from-from everyone else.
IG: 28:06
There were enough of you.
EW: 28:07
Yeah, there were about eight of us, so it was not that many.
IG: 28:10
Yeah.
EW: 28:10
And we were very tight, and we were very clannish in a way. Clannish, you know, the small stage.
IG: 28:17
What happened to the seven?
EW: 28:20
Well, we-we-we all graduated, and people went different ways. I had not seen most people for 30 years. I mean, I until last year, I went to a reunion. I mean, I-I moved around a lot, both for my own and my ex-wife's careers; moved around a whole lot. Though in the (19)70s, I was still in the late (19)70s until my ex-wife and I left New York in (19)83. I was still active in the community center in Brooklyn. But I think people who went through that organization, although probably all of us are very critical in retrospect, people went on to do very progressive things. A lot of people became teachers, teacher advocates, teacher trainees. A lot of people went into labor organization. I mean, one friend is runs. I think the labor education program for $11.99. Another friend ran labor education programs in Penn State. So, in that regard, People, [crosstalk] yeah, yeah, it definitely was. Even though people dissipated, and the community became very difficult, very rough. When I started going out to the community center. 1967 or thereabouts, and I lived in Bayside. It would take me two hours. I would go by bus and train all the way to Manhattan, all across Queens into Manhattan, and all the way out on the New Lots line to the second-to-last stop, Van Siclen Avenue, and you could do that. But then by 1970, it was actually too dangerous to walk even a few blocks from Van Siclen Avenue to the community center offices. The community center still exists, but it is more a social service agency than a community organizing place that it was in those days.
IG: 30:40
And I think that there is something poignant about being shaped by this rich culture that you did not know died out.
EW: 30:55
Yeah, right. Yeah, we were we were like the last lingering elements of it, which I think most of us did not quite realize at the time. I should have realized it because I was researching communism.
IG: 31:08
No, but it is more. I think it is more psychological.
EW: 31:12
Yeah, yeah.
IG: 31:15
So, how do you think your classmates would remember you during that time?
EW: 31:26
If any of them remember me, it would probably be as a member of this weird organization that was causing havoc on campus.
IG: 31:38
So, do you think that they would have looked upon you and that organization favorably, or just as something or?
EW: 31:46
Probably more strange than fad than favorably.
IG: 31:50
So did you, did you feel integrated into-
EW: 31:56
Campus?
IG: 31:57
Wider-wider milieu-
EW: 31:59
Campus? Yeah, yeah, sure. I did. I also played intramural football.
IG: 32:04
Okay, so tell us about that.
EW: 32:05
I played football in high school. I played intramural football. The only time I ever got hurt was playing intramural football. So, I had this kind of schizophrenic life in a way. But we also, I also hung out with these guys. I do not know whatever happened to them. I remembered very clearly. We had this table in the snack bar, and two guys were studying medieval history. I was studying Russian history. A couple, another guy, and we would sit at the table and read and talk, study and talk. So, I remember that fondly. I do not know what happened to any of them, and I do not remember their names. But yeah, I certainly felt integrated into the larger college.
IG: 33:00
Somebody said, you know, quite a number of people said that at Harpur College they feel that they receive the kind of education, undergraduate liberal arts education, that one would get at an elite private college.
EW: 33:18
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, I did not know that at the time. I had no experience in private colleges until I went to BU, which I disliked immensely. And then my first job was at St. Olaf College, and that was a totally different experience. That was my first experience of a small liberal arts college, and I had to tone down my New Yorkies there. That was because it is a Lutheran, also a Lutheran college. There was an immediate cultural clash with the students, so I had to learn-learn to be more estranged, and learn that irony, let alone sarcasm, does not work in the middle Midwest, especially at a Lutheran institution. But yeah, as I said, I mean, I-I still remember also my Litton Comp 101, which was taught by this renowned Joyce scholar. It was taught by two guys. Maybe both of them were renowned Joyce scholars. Cannot remember their names. But so, this had to have been fall 1970 when I started and took the mandatory lit and comp course. It was great. I loved it, and you know it served me well all my academic career. I drew on and still draw on things I read in Com. What I read in that two-semester Russian literature class; other literature classes I took. Yeah.
IG: 35:05
You were also in Germany. You lived in Germany and studied. So, what was that? When at what point did you?
EW: 35:13
Well, aside from, you know, traveling, backpacking, hitchhiking as a teenager, I went to Germany seriously in (19)79, (19)80 to do my dissertation research to West Germany. Yeah, that was a whole different experience. I mean, I was a naive American. My German was not very good then either. I-I could read, but my spoken German was not good. I mean, now it is fine. But I was studying the history of communism, labor history, and obviously there is, you know, the connection to my political activism in those days and what I was studying, and I was going to a center of labor history research in Bochum, in the Ruhr, Germany's one of Germany's major industrial regions, social democratic, in those days run state, North Rhine-Westphalia. I was just totally unprepared for the hierarchy and conservatism of West German academic culture. I was just
IG: 36:31
It is a carryover from the 19th century, indeed.
EW: 36:34
Indeed, a carryover from the 19th century, which you know has only been partially revised in this century, partially reformed in this century. So, I mean, I learned an immense amount. I did the dissertation research I had to do, and then I came back with an IREX grant, yeah, to East Germany in 1984 to do some postdoctoral research, and that was back.
IG: 37:12
When were you? Where were you then?
EW: 37:14
That was in Halle, in-in Prussian Saxony, as it was called Sachsen-Anhalt today, and that was the height of the German Democratic Republic, 1984. After that came the stagnation and decline, leading to the collapse in (19)89, (19)90. And by then, my wife and I had a baby, so we all went. It was very interesting. It was very interesting. Well, you know, in many-many ways. I mean, East Germans always looked to the West, to West Germany, as a point of comparison for consumer goods and all of that. And sure, the consumer goods were very, very limited, but you know, was not bad. I had no idea how extensive the network of spying was. You know, I had no idea until 1989, but nobody else did either. So, or at least nobody else outside. I mean, I was totally surprised when the wall came down about the extensiveness of the internal surveillance network. So, for example, we became very friendly with the secretary in the history department at the University Martin Luther University, Halle Wittenberg, and we had them over to our apartment in Halle in 1984, and they had us over to theirs, and I had no idea that they were actually running risks by doing that. Not until the collapse did it dawn on me that would become clear.
IG: 39:14
Do you know what happened to them after?
EW: 39:15
No, I lost contact with them. I saw them. I was back in early (19)89, in late August, early September (19)89, a few months before the wall came down. And as I often, when people ask me to predict something, I often say that you know, I then came, I came back from there, and I we had also become friendly with my advisor and his family, and I was there on my own at that time, and I went up with them to their dacha, as they always ironically called it in in the Harz Mountains. So, my advisor was, of course, a party member. Socialists, all university professors, were their friends. We were all party members, enterprise directors, physicians, and so. And I remember an evening with them, September 1989, and they were all totally depressed. They saw things changing in Poland and Czechoslovakia, and nothing happening in East Germany.
IG: 40:25
What year is this?
EW: 40:26
1989. So in October 1989, at Saint Olaf College, I told the class in German history, no less, that the wall would be with us for the rest of our lives. Four weeks later, the whole thing is gone. The whole thing is gone. So-so much for my predictive abilities.
IG: 40:45
Have you seen the Stasi installation at the Metropolitan Museum?
EW: 40:50
No. This is a Stasi installation at the Met, really.
IG: 40:53
Yeah.
EW: 40:54
Yeah. I mean, there was clearly a report on me in the what was called the Gault Office now because my advisor again we became very friendly and I did maintain contact with him and his family for many years. I have never looked to see it. One of these days I will, I expect, because he clearly had to file reports on me, so.
IG: 41:25
Well, it is interesting what-what files will be.
EW: 41:30
Well, they will all be available. They will all be available. Whatever-whatever is there will be available.
IG: 41:35
Congratulations very much about those files. It is about the bureaucracy of the Staffi headquarters and the nullity of its evil; you know, it is, it is very good. So, you know, what did you think? You know, just for the record, tell us a little bit about your career after Minnesota. Where did you? Where are you now? And what did you do? You have been at CCNNY for years.
EW: 42:16
Well, not that long. Since well-well, to-to-to run backwards a little bit from Binghamton, I went to Boston University, did my dissertation. My wife and I moved around a lot, too long to, too involved to-to relate all of that. Finished my dissertation (19)83. We were living in Southern Illinois because she is a physician. She had a public health service scholarship in Tufts, and she owed the feds two years' work in a what the feds called, at the time, a health manpower shortage area. She did a training in Mount Sinai, so we went from a Mount Sinai apartment on Park Avenue and 96th Street to a town of 5,000 people and 35 churches in rural Southern Illinois. I had never been west of Pittsburgh. I did not know what this was. I spent two years looking for a job. Did not find anything academic job, and then we moved to Minnesota for my ex-wife to do her training in hematology-oncology, and then I found a job at Saint Olaf College, where I was for 14 years, and then moved to the University of Minnesota in 1999, and faculty member there for 13 years, and then 2012 was recruited to City College of New York as the dean of humanities and arts with a mandate to build the humanities, which I was very-very happy to do so.
IG: 44:02
And you were a distinguished professor at CCNY and the University.
EW: 44:06
Yeah, yeah. I was I held two chairs at the University of Minnesota, an endowed chair endowed by an Armenian gentleman in Minneapolis, Arsham Ojanessian, that gave me that was devoted to issues of nationalism and human rights, within which there had to be attention to the Armenian genocide, and I had a distinguished McKnight University professorship at Minnesota, and then I came to CCNY and became a distinguished professor here as well.
IG: 44:46
So that is that is-
EW: 44:47
So.
IG: 44:48
You kind of shifted to human rights.
EW: 44:52
Well, I have for the last 15 years kind of tacked back and forth between German history and global history, and in particular the history of genocides and the history of human rights. So, my second book was a history of genocides in the 20th century.
IG: 45:15
That is fascinating. Is there a sort of a common cause for genocide, or is every genocide different?
EW: 45:24
Both things are true. Both-both points are true. I mean, there are certainly common patterns, and one of the very common patterns is an ideology and propaganda of exclusion. To put it in the most neutral and general terms, but it off but it often involves a rhetoric of debasement about the other, and the other is usually defined in national or racial terms, and that you can see as consistency, at least in 20th century, genocides running from the Herero and Nama of Namibia in the early part of the century through the Armenians, through Jews, the Holocaust, through Rwanda and Burundi.
IG: 46:17
Do you consider the Ukrainian famine a genocide?
EW: 46:20
I do not. I do not because if one follows the UN definition, the UN Convention of 1948, and scholars argue all the time about whether we should follow that convention or not, the issue of intent is primary in that convention, and I do not think Stalin's intent was to eliminate the Ukrainian population. I think it was the result of completely failed and inhumane development policies. I would say the same about Mao's Great Leap Forward, which killed them. Some of the estimates are that 40 million people died-died of famine- but I do not think there was an intent to eliminate the Ukrainian population as such.
IG: 47:12
Maybe a certain class of the Ukrainian population. I do not want to get into an argument.
EW: 47:18
Yeah, I know it is it is-
IG: 47:23
Yeah, because actually my family lived alongside the family because and-and you know all right well that
EW: 47:32
Maybe another time. I mean, one of my mentors, Norman Naymark, I am going to his retirement party next week at Stanford. I mean, he would argue that it was a genocide, and lots of people would. I do not see it, but-but it was, a it was a huge tragedy of that. There is no question.
IG: 47:58
So, so just continue. Is-is, you know, your career your-your books were on what you know what just give us the span of your writings.
EW: 48:09
So, the first book, as I mentioned, was a history of German communism from pre beginnings in the 1890s to the collapse of the German Democratic Republic. Then I wrote this book, A Century of genocide. The third book brought me back to German history, Weimar Germany: Promise and Tragedy, which, in terms of sales, has been the most successful of my books.
IG: 48:35
And what is the title of this book?
EW: 48:37
And the-the Weimar book?
IG: 48:40
Yes. In terms of sales, what is the name of the book?
EW: 48:43
Weimar Germany: Promise and Tragedy, and that gets used a lot in courses. And that-that book was a labor of love because that is what really got me involved in German history, the 1920s, the fact that Germany had the largest socialist and communist movements, all of the artistic, cultural, sexual experimentation of the 1920s. Most of my colleagues in German history and German studies come into the field via the Holocaust and the Third Reich. For me, it was really the 1920s, and I pushed the Nazis to the last chapter and argued that we should not read the triumph of the Third Reich back into the Weimar period, and should take the Weimar period on-on we should take the Weimar period on its own terms. And the-the next book, which will be out this September, is called A World Divided: The Global Struggle for Human Rights in the Age of Nation-states.
IG: 50:05
And what is that about?
EW: 50:05
And it is both an affirmative history of human rights is the best thing we have going for us, but also a critical history in the sense that it deals with the difficulties, the complexities, the always partial nature of human rights advances, and it is-it is a global history. It covers virtually every continent and specific cases drawn from virtually every continent since the late 18th century to the present. I have been working on that one for about 15 years.
IG: 50:37
15 years.
EW: 50:38
Yeah.
IG: 50:41
So, you know, we are wrapping up a little bit, and you know what I would like to ask is, for your wisdom at the conclusion of this interview, and for the young people who are listening, who will be listening to this interview, what-what do you think were the most important lessons that you have learned during your college years at Harpur College? What-what you know, kind of what words of-of wisdom can you learn?
EW: 51:18
For me, a liberal arts education-oops, sorry. For me, a liberal arts education with very few requirements was absolutely wonderful, and I do not know what the curriculum is like today, and I know in the sciences and engineering it is much more difficult, but I think college should be a time where, at least to some extent, you experiment, you branch out, you take things that sound interesting that you might not be good at or you might not be familiar with, that you open yourself up to literatures, other histories, other ways of knowing, other forms of inquiry. That is what college should be. College is not just training you for a job, and we actually we do that in the humanities very well, despite all the attacks the humanities have been under for years now in the United States, but the way you learn to think in the humanities and arts, the way you learn to research, to write in all of the various disciplines, sciences as well as the humanities, that is what is so important about college. Do not just stay within courses, disciplines you are comfortable with. Take advantage of all of the great faculty and all of the great offerings that exist, and also be aggressive about your education. That is what I tell my students at CCNY. Now we there is this complete obsession in this country with the elite universities, but it is the publics that educate 80 percent of American students, and you will not be as coddled in public universities, you might have to be a little more aggressive. You know, just be aggressive. Find the best professors. Find the best classes in whatever field there is, and go for it.
IG: 53:35
Thank you. That-that is great advice, and I thank you for an excellent interview, and it has been a pleasure.
EW: 53:44
It has been a pleasure for me.
(End of Interview)
Date of Interview
2019-04-02
Interviewer
Irene Gashurov
Year of Graduation
1974
Interviewee
Dr. Eric D. Weitz
Biographical Text
Dr. Eric Weitz (1953–2021) was a distinguished historian specializing in modern European and global history, with pioneering scholarship on genocide, human rights, and nation-states. Raised in Bayside, Queens, he graduated from Harpur College at Binghamton University in 1973 and earned his graduate degrees at Boston University. He taught at St. Olaf College and the University of Minnesota before becoming Dean of Humanities and Arts at the City College of New York in 2012. A committed humanitarian, Weitz was active in the civil rights and anti-Vietnam War movements and remained dedicated to inclusive higher education throughout his career.
Interview Format
Audio
Rights Statement
Many items in our digital collections are copyrighted. If you want to reuse any material in our collection you must seek permission, or decide if your purpose can qualify as fair use under the U.S. Copyright Law Section 107. If you think copyright or privacy has been violated, the University Libraries will investigate the issue. Please see our take down policy. If using any materials in this online digital collection for educational or research purposes, please cite accordingly.
Citation
“Interview with Dr. Eric D. Weitz,” Digital Collections, accessed November 17, 2026, https://omeka.binghamton.edu/omeka/items/show/2417.