Skip to main content
Libraries

Oral Interview with Martin Montalvo

:: ::

Title

Oral Interview with Martin Montalvo

Creator

Montalvo, Martin

Contributor

Burbano, Mariapaz

Subject

Binghamton University; Educational Opportunity Program; Special Admissions Program

Description

Martin Montalvo was a student who came through the Special Admisstions Program program in the early 1970s and graduated from Binghamton University in 1975. In this interview, he shares his personal journey to Binghamton in the early 1970s, influenced by the Vietnam War draft and a chance encounter with a former classmate. He reflects on his experiences as a student, including navigating his identity as a Puerto Rican from Brooklyn, the social dynamics of the "third world corridor," dealing with prejudice, and the formative relationships he built. He discusses the impact of the Civil Rights Movement and historical events like the Attica prison uprising on his perspective, the challenges and growth he experienced, and he offers advice to current students to pursue their passions and learn to navigate a diverse world.

Identifier

MMontalvo.mp4

Date Created

2025-03-21

Date Modified

2025-03-21

License

Copyright held by the State University at Binghamton

Is Part Of

Educational Opportunity Program at Binghamton University records

Extent

1:07:41

Medium

mp4

Transcription

[Start of interview]

MB: 00:02
Alright, so today's date is March 21, 2025. My name is Mariapaz Burbano. I'm a graduate student at Binghamton University pursuing my master's degree in human rights, and I'm interviewing Martin Montalvo using the virtual meeting platform Zoom. The purpose of this interview is to talk about the early history of programs that provided broader access to higher education at Binghamton University, namely, the Educational Opportunity Program and related programs. Martin, could you please say and spell your full name and indicate your verbal consent to be recorded for this project?

MM: 00:38
Okay. My name is Martin Montalvo, and I'm sorry, did you say spell also?

MB: 00:42
Yes, please.

MM: 00:43
Okay. First Name, M, A, R, T, I N, last name, M, O, N, T, A, L, V, like victory, O, and I do consent. I do consent to the interview.

MB: 00:53
Okay, perfect. Thank you. Alright, so to start off, would you want to talk a little bit about the life experiences that led you to SAP?

MM: 01:09
Okay, sure, I knew nothing about the program—first let me let you know—so I grew up in the late, you know, in the 60s, and I like to say we—in the (19)70s we were in our 20s, now in the (20)20s, we're in our 70s, so it's a lot of time in between. So when I graduated high school, I had no idea—I'm from Brooklyn, New York—so usually New Yorkers have this bad—and I don't think it's an attitude, I think you think that the whole world is New York City, so I didn't think beyond Brooklyn or the five boroughs or anything like that. The Vietnam War was hot and heavy at the time. My older brother had volunteered for the army, and he was taken to Vietnam. He was very gung ho, supporting the government, and a couple of things led me to come to Binghamton. Firstly, he gave me a call from Japan, and he said, “Whatever you do, don't let them bring you over here. Even if you have to run to Canada, I don't care what you have to do, it's a lot of malarkey.” He used different words, but he said it's a lot of malarkey over here. It's not what they're saying it is. I was in high school, maybe I had 80’s, 70’s, 80-ish, average. So I had no thoughts about going to college, my saving—I guess you think like maybe you're predestined to do it. I was in the chorus in high school, and when we graduated, I just—I went to work for a bank that's no longer in existence, it's manufacturers, Hanover Trusts, and I worked on Wall Street, and on my trip home in the subway, I ran into a girl I used to sing with. Name is Anaida Colon. She's also a graduate of the EOP program, brilliant, brilliant girl, I think she's in Mex—California right now. Wonderful girl. And she ran into me at the Union Square Station, I believe it was. And said, “Hi, how are you doing?” You know, the whole big, oh, what you have—what have you been doing? And I let her know, and she told me, “Have you heard about the—“ I think it was called the SA program at the time, Special Admissions program. So I don't know what that is, so she went through a whole spiel about it on the subway station, gave me a bunch of information. I pursued it, especially after my brother told me, “Don't let them get you into Vietnam”, because I was already—I was turning 19, and I already got my notice for a physical exam for the army. I went to the physical, and then they, I didn't ask for it, but they made an appointment for me to visit a Marine recruiter. And being, you know, just being—working all the time, for the first time—I used to go to school, used to get, you know, your time off or holidays off. There's no holidays when you're working—

MB: 04:22
Right. [crosstalk] Right. [crosstalk]

MM: 04:22
—so I took—they gave me the day off from work. I said, I'll take the day off to go see the Marine recruiter. So I walked into the Marine recruiter's office, and apparently they were not prepared for new people coming in to be interviewed. And he was—the sergeant who was there was very annoyed because he had not been prepared. So he turned to another sergeant and he said, “Hey, did they tell you we had to do this today?” The other sergeant said, “No.” So he just, instead of giving me the sales talk, what—he went right to the point, and he said, “Hey, man, you want to join the Marines?” I said, “No, I don't.” He said, “Well, then get the hell out of here. We're going to get your—we're going to get your ass anyway.” And that I said, “No, you're not.” And then boom, Anaida came right to mind. So I pursued the program, and I can't—I don't remember the exact chronology of it, but the best I can tell you, the next thing, I took a short line to a city I never heard of called Binghamton. I got off the short line and I said, What the hell am I doing here? Took a bus to the administration building where the SA program had a bunch of counselors, which are the upperclassmen. My counselor happened to be a gentleman named Dan Durett, who graduated in (19)72, and as a matter of fact, he was part of the meeting yesterday with my group, and I got introduced to the State University of Binghamton. It was called SUNY Binghamton at the time. Now I know it's Binghamton University. It was also actually turning from Harpur College to SUNY Binghamton at the time, maybe 1,500, 1,700 students. So it was like a small community. And then I got introduced to classmates, I got introduced to upperclassmen. I got introduced to J.B., John Benson, who was—I think he was running the program at the time, and Ted McKee, who is a federal judge now. And then I walked into a room and I met Ronnie McBride. And Ronnie, he was from New England, Batavia, Massachusetts, that area, originally, I think he was from Georgia. And as he will tell you, he will say, he once said, “I don't have enough. I don't have a license to carry this much coal.” I said, “What do you mean by that?” He said, “Look how Black I am. I shouldn't be this Black.” So we hit it off. Short—long story short, we hit it off, and we always say we were blessed because we walked into that room totally colorblind. So we hit it off. To this day, he's one of my best friends. He's baptized one of my daughters. I baptized his firstborn. He was best man at my wedding. So that's a bond that the orientation was able to provide for a lot of us who attended orientation and that—it's already 50 years, and you know, we're still in touch, we're still together. He was a good person to be with. He had a lot more life experiences. He was on his own a lot longer than I was. This is the first time I was on my own. I'm away from home, bunch of people that I had never met before—and then that's when you your mind starts to open up. Hey, you know something, New York City isn't the only place in the world. And this is small Binghamton that I'm looking at this small Binghamton, and all of a sudden, this is an opening, because I'm meeting people from Buffalo, Indiana, California. So, I'm meeting people from the islands. And to—for me and like I like to say, if you interviewed 38 of us going to school at the same time, you're still going to get 38 different stories. Because the first thing we try to do is—[phone ringtone] and that's my wife's phone, please forgive me.

MB: 08:33
[laughs] No it’s okay.

MM: 08:37
I try to find out where do I fit in all of this. I wasn't supposed to be in college. I'm not that confident in my verbal skills, my writing skills, my math skills. What am I doing here? So you try to, as I like to say, you try to fake it, I'm going to fit in. And one of the things that they had at the time, which I think—I was at a homecoming two years ago, and one of the students said, “I heard there was a legend that you were—all the Black students and Latin students live on that.” I said, “That's not a legend, that was called the third world corridor.” So we had the opportunity, which was great, because you got to be with people you were comfortable with, who was—you know, I'm in my mind, coming from New York, you live with the TV programs you see, and you grow up with Ozzy and Harriet and Leave It to Beaver, and there's all these White kids going to school, and it's like a shake up. So you're put in with people you're comfortable with, and some of them are more like you, others—others were there strictly for business. Get a bunch of books. Go into a room, shut the door, and just, you know, get your work done, because I want to be out of here in three years. I want to be out—you know. So they already had their mind set, but I didn't know what I wanted to do. I didn't—I never expected to be there. So it was a slow, a slow change, but it was wonderful—for me—there was a lot of growing up to do. My background is—my parents are from Puerto Rico, so they had BSU, Black Student Union, and then you had what they called Azabache at the time, which now I think it turned into LASU.

MB: 10:41
Mhm, right.

MM: 10:42
And the [inaudible] was, you have to find out who you are in yourself, because when I went to Azabache, you know, you get, “Well, what are you, oh you’re Puerto Rican? Oh you can come in.” So they start asking me questions about Puerto Rico. I've never been to Puerto Rico. I only know Brooklyn, so all of a sudden, I'm not Puerto Rican enough. I know nothing of the politics. So you know you're like in limbo. I'm also—I'm also not Black, but in Brooklyn, that's who my friends were, so I tended to identify more with them. The funny thing is, when I went to to Binghamton, a few things happened socially. That's the first place I learned how to Latin, how to do salsa. But as time goes on—I have this personal joke that I always say to to my Black friends and to the friends that I meet, I say, “I used to be Black.” They say, “What do you mean? You used to be Black?” I said, “Well, I was Black until I couldn't keep up with your handshake. You know, you kept changing the handshake, so I had to turn my card in.” So that's kind of—it's beautiful, because it breaks the ice, and they understand what I mean. But it was, it was totally trying to—to find out and where the world fit around me. And you can fake it as much as you want out there on campus, but once you go to your room and you shut the door, you can't fake it anymore, because that's you. But it was a wonderful, wonderful experience for me to to be there, to actually get my diploma. I wasn't supposed to be there, but I actually got my diploma. It took five years, but I did it. And kind of to learn more about myself. It was a wonderful program. It took a lot of turns, it was some good times, some bad times. We lost a few people. A young man was shot in Binghamton when I was there. I think they have a basketball tournament in his name now, there was other deaths. There was—naturally life goes on. So some people lost parents. One of my roommates, we were a triple room at the time, lost his brother. So you—it's a growing process. I met my wife there. We're still married, so it'll be forty-nine years this year that we're together.

MB: 13:10
Congrats [laughs].

MM: 13:12
So and—different people, you see how different people react to different things. Drugs scared the hell out of me. Didn't touch anything while I was there, because I saw what happened to some people who did. The support of EOP was wonderful. If you didn't feel like you were good in English or something, they set up courses for you. They set up tutoring for you. They helped you in any way they could. I found, though, that if the students helped themselves, that was a great security. My roommate, as I say, Ronnie, was a security, but there are also a lot of people there people are going to be people. Some people try to use you. You don't know it. Everybody—when you meet an upperclassman, you think they've got the answer to everything, whatever question they got the answer, and the answer might—they do have an answer, but you don't know if the answer is for you or they're trying to manipulate you. So it's all it's a growing process, but it was, and still is, that’s why I'm trying to kind of organize a reunion, because there's a lot of thank yous that I have to give to my classmates.

MB: 14:43
Right. So I know you mentioned the importance of historical events that were happening at that time, how that pushed you to make certain decisions. So would you please elaborate a little bit more on what other historical events were occurring at that time?

MM: 15:03
Okay well, the first thing, as I mentioned, Vietnam was going on. Okay, and I was—when I was working, I only worked for a year before I went to Binghamton, but when I was working, during a lunch break on—when I was on Wall Street, there was an anti-war march that was taking place. You can probably still get—if you Google it, you can probably still see that what happened was the construction workers on site, they came down and they attacked the students. So there was a big riot right there in front of George Washington, right on Wall Street. So there was a big riot there, and um, being very—you don't know what's going on in your head, because the government tells you one thing, you're fighting this communism and everything, and as the students say no, it's an unjust war. So until you start to do other research, you find that, you know, yeah, you want to be patriotic, but you don't want to do something that's totally wrong in your head. That's where I found out the phrase was always love your country, but that doesn't mean always love your government. And coming from high school, I didn't know how to separate the two. That's where I started to learn how to separate the two, between my brother calling me from Vietnam, seeing the riots that was taking place, and also living in the neighborhood I lived in because I was probably the only Puerto Rican in my group, seeing the—how the Black students and people were being treated. But the awakening was also that al—[laughs], although I was their friend, as as the emotions started coming up, every once in a while, I found out I wasn't part of them. I was with them, but I wasn't part of them. One time, I made a statement of, “Yeah—“ I was growing up, maybe I was just going into high school, “—yeah, those White folks, they think they're better than us.” And one of the friends that I grew up with, who happened to be Black, looked at me and said, “Look who's talking about us.” And it hit me like a shot that, whoa, you know. So you kind of have to try and find your place, and not depend on other people to show you where you fit in. And the first place I had to fit in was in here, in my head, was the—this was the big enemy was here. I stole my own dreams. So there was—it was Vietnam. It was the Civil Rights Movement. You have to remember and (19)63 when Kennedy got shot, I think that was my awakening, I was twelve years old. And then Malcolm X got killed, and I was fourteen. And then Martin Luther King and RFK, I was seventeen. So through those years, all I saw was an unraveling of what I thought America was, and I'm—and that's why being here today, it kind of shakes me up, because I thought we were coming apart at the seams then, with the riots in Chicago, with the Democratic Convention, I mean, that was horrific, and the riots in my own Brooklyn neighborhood. And then to go through all that, and then to graduate, and I find—I found a job, you know, when I left college, and you think that everything is getting better, and then to come back to the state that we're in now, and I'm more scared now than I was then, because I didn't see an attack from so deep within as I do now. It's really scary, and like my wife says it's not so much—I’m going to be seventy-four—excuse me—but I've got grandkids, I’ve got four grandkids that the youngest is three, and the oldest is going to be seventeen. And when I was fifteen, the Vietnam war was going on, but I said, “Ah I'm fifteen, I don't have to worry about that.” But it was still hot and heavy when I graduated high school, so I'm thinking, I’ve got a grandson who's going to be fifteen, in three years he's eight—what's he going to be? What's—three years, and Trump is still going to be in office. I don't know what he's going to walk into as a young man. So that's—it's very, very scary. And then you go to campus which was [laughs]—which is actually wonderful, but then you also have to choose up sides on campus, because you have the militance that was going on. You have some folks who want to do it together, Latinos, Blacks, and some folks who say, “No, we're separate, two separate cultures.” So there's a lot of different sides that you have to juggle and that can be very tricky on your head also. But I think mostly—the outward(??) things were the Civil Rights Movement and the movement for, you know, Black awareness. My problem also was that my parents were older. My mom had me when she was 40. She came here from Puerto Rico to try and get her dad here. He died in (19)45 while she was here, she never got to see him buried. He had a farm, story goes that the U.S. Army took over the farm, and so he lost his farm. So, when my parents came here, their whole thing, like every other immigrant, was try and fit in, try and—so I spoke Spanish until I was five, but after that, you saw totally English, totally English, totally English. So you try to fit in, whereas a lot of the students who were Binghamton, their parents were a lot younger. So naturally, it's not so much survival, but they grew up more like more militant. So it's not only the culture, but the age differences in your mind, not so much chronologically, but in your head. I was a little bit, Why? Why is all this trouble happening? And you kind of have to wake up into that. There was an—there was an uprising in Attica when I was in school, that was very bothersome also. You can do research on that also, where the guards were killed in Attica with that uprising, and come to find out the guards were killed mostly by guards because they went in shooting without knowing what they were shooting at, they were just angry that the prisoners took over and all of this was taking place. And so there's a lot of turmoil going on in your head, and at the same time, you're thinking about when I get out of here, what am I going to do? How am I going to live? I'm already—I graduated in (19)75 I was married in (19)76, so now you're thinking about a family. There's a whole bunch of things that are going through your head. Survival, [laughs] getting—and at the same time you have to worry about, what, getting a paper in on time? Oh my god, I have to do this research, and can get the paper in on time. Or do I have to go to this prof ask, and ask him for more time? Or—you know, but it was wonderful in that when you were there, you're in a bubble. You really are. You’re in—there was no cell phones. The big trip every once in a while was when you you caught the OCC bus to Vesta Plaza. There was only one or two OCC busses at the time. And if you lived off campus and you missed the morning bus and you had a morning class because you didn't have a car, you missed that class. When you did your research, you didn't pop open a computer. You had to run to the library, and you had to find the books in the stacks. Sometimes the book was there, sometimes it wasn't. The cultural was wonderful also, we had [inaudible] board with a Latin Caribbean dance. It was wonderful. I was tutored—not tutored—but I took a class with Lofton Mitchell, the writer. I mean, some magnificent things were happening in my life, but I also found that I was my own worst enemy in that I was a history major, and I love history, but my passion was singing. I don't think anybody but my roommate and my wife know that. So that, you know, you’re kind of your own worst enemy. If I were there now, I would tell any student, I said, “This may not be for you, but if you're—grab your passion, because life starts coming at you, you fall in love. You have to survive. But grab your passion and do the best you can with it. Because you're going to be seventy-five one day, and then you're going to look—what did I do?” I don't know if I'm going off track with all of this, but those would—and also, at the same time, you know, you're doing all of this, and in my case—and your parents don't understand. My parents came from Puerto Rico just to survive. So what's all this stuff? [inaudible] Just keep your head down. You got a job, you know, just—you don't need all of this trouble. So it—and I think it's—and I'm talking about me—but I'm sure it's a—juggling, like for most of the students. Ronnie McBride, my roommate, he was going—dead set on becoming a corporate lawyer. He met his wife there too, and so—and funny, his wife's name is Yvonne. My wife's name is Yvonne. [MB laughs] She became an optometrist. They became partners. Had a great business. Unfortunately, he lost her a few years ago. That's another reason I wanted to see everybody, because we're starting to drop out [laughs]. So, we—this may be our last chance. But um, he was going to be a lawyer. But what happened? You fall in love and you start making your way, and so he became his(??) partner. He became an optician, she became an optometrist. They opened up a wonderful business. So that's another reason to [inaudible] because things come along that you don't realize, you know, but you have to grab it.

MB: 15:07
Mhm. Right.

MM: 27:08
And you also don't know a lot of these people are very passionate, and what they say, a lot of the upperclassmen, and you come back years later and find out they went totally in a different—they were leading you in one direction, but they went in a totally different direction. So it's a great growing experience. It's just life. That's all it is, is life, and you hope that you can come out the other side. So I think it—this, what you're doing, is important, but I think it's also important to understand that, like I say, you get thirty-eight people, it could be in the same dorm, you're going to get thirty-eight different stories.

MB: 27:52
Right. So speaking of the students and the diversity and backgrounds and life paths. Do you remember—how do you remember the students’ adaptation to the program and university life at that point?

MM: 28:18
Some students, I find some students were almost like me. Some students from the islands, they came in and—not all of them, but some of them had—it was one girl in particular, she [inaudible] have a very negative attitude toward the Blacks that are from the States, they kind of looked down on them and that was odd to me, but it's a reality. And they were there—seemed like, for the books. You have to get [inaudible]. For the upperclassmen that had been there for a while, they were also there for the books, but they were in their—more militant, not all of them again, but the militancy was there, and you always felt that there was a—and it sounds almost silly now, but that there was going to be some type of big change. They used to be an album called The Last Poets. They always talked about, “When the revolution comes, when the revolution comes.” They were Puerto Ricans that was saying something's going to happen and Puerto Rico is going to break away. There was such militance in one end, and then on the other end, there was those that, you know, let's just—I just want to get out of here, build my life, become a professional. But you always knew that there was also that prejudice. Now I'll give you an example. Endicott lounge, we had the third world corridor, and there was an election for the dorm president. The third world corridor consisted of—the upper floor was all ladies, the lower floor was all guys, but we all had meetings. We took a meeting in the lounge, and we decided who—we were going to put one person in to run. And we decided that all our votes, all of our votes, would go for that one person. In the meantime, the rest of the dorm was White, and they had three or four people, you know, that they put in naturally. But since all of our votes went for that one person, he happened to win. His name was Ricky, I remember, and he won, and the rest of the dorm was outraged. How could we—they were the majority, how could there be a Black president of the dorm? Come to find out after that, he used to get notes slipped under his door, n word, go home. We know you stuffed the ballot box, you know. And it was to the extent that he almost had a breakdown. It was that bad. So you had to deal with that. That was on campus also. So that's the reality, and that also tends to make you not want to deal with the other—I call the other—I don't mean the other side, but with the White students. So I had very few White students that I dealt with, and that was not good, because when you leave the university, you got to deal with the world as it is, not being able to to interact with White students. And a few students did interact with White students, and unfortunately, the other side of the coin is they were ostracized. So it's a double-edged sword. So one of the things that happened because of that, and I can see why it happened, you know, the third world corridor, they did away with it. But when that happened, what happened was a lot of the students, then they moved off campus, so there was still that schism. And it's very important—I mean, it's very important to be who you are, but you also have to deal with everybody else who's around you, otherwise, it carries through when you leave the university and it can be a bumpy ride. But yeah, that—I hardly—you get up in the morning, you pass a White student who you may have passed them three years, but you never said hi to him. That's not good. Although my roommate Ronnie McBride, he always treated everyone just as he was treated. And he says, he said, “I'm not from New York, I'm from New England. You have to deal with that all the time.” And you don't know when you may have to ask somebody for a ride or something, but you have to deal with their—that you can't treat them as invisible, just like you don't want them to treat you as if you're invisible. And I don't know how it is now, but out in the world, out here, thank god it didn't carry through for me. I know it did for some people, but you have to go out and you have to deal with real people, and your boss, your boss may one day be pink with purple stripes. You still have to deal with them [laughter].

MB: 34:20
So kind of moving on from the students’ experience to a reflection on the institutional culture of the university, how do you think that it affected the success of the program and the success of the students?

MM: 34:41
There was—we had some, I think we had some really great success, as far as other students. We had a young upperclassman named Glenn Abbott. I think he was—he was an all-star baseball player, I believe. He was all-American. We had students that brought up—especially the athletic value was great because we had some great basketball players come in. Ronnie—I never ran track, Ronnie McBride got me to run the mile. I never ran track, and I mean, I wasn't like a champion runner, but I never thought I could run for two hours straight. Also, you learn how to—and this is very important, because a lot of times you feel things, but you don't know how to articulate it. And the ability to be able to articulate your feelings is such a release, and so important, not only for you, but when you articulate it, you're touching somebody who's feeling the same thing and they don't know how to articulate it and then when they hear you, they, “Oh, that's what's going on,” not only in racial—in relationship with other races, but in relationship with the opposite sex. It's an eye opener. It's so important to be there, to grow up there, to see that there's some courses you're pretty good at, you didn't think you were going to be pretty good at, with the help of the administration, with the help of—there was John Yadel(??), who—[laughs] when new students were coming in, he’d—he always called them my babies, and he tried to protect his babies from the upperclassmen, because some of the upperclassmen didn't mean to do any good with his babies. But you try to ease them in. I hated to leave the university, because that was—let me give you an example. We were—we got so close, and then you go home for Christmas break, and I go home to Brooklyn after saying hi, and everything(??), and you walk out in the street, and now you're totally paranoid, because you don't know what—you're back in Brooklyn, and you know what Brooklyn is like, and all of a sudden, what am I doing out here in the street? It's dangerous. But you—I did so many things. I went to—I visited Colgate, I visited Syracuse, I visited—you know, you go to places you never thought. I was as close to—in a concert—to Kool & The Gang, as I am to the door right here, I was sitting that close to them. And you wonder, you know, this would had never have taken place. I was taught a lesson by Ronnie McBride, he wanted to get into the politics, and he was the treasurer of BSU. And I said, “Ronnie, why treasurer? Why not, you know, why don't you want to be the president of BSU?” And he said, “Because the power is where the money is.” So you learn lessons like that. So you know something, he's right. And his main—[laughs] one of his main goals, he told me as a freshman, he says, “I grew up with The Temptations. I'm going to bring them on campus.” You know, he did it. He brought them on campus. He brought Smokey Robinson on campus. He was very articulate, and he had a very high antenna for measuring people up. That's what I learned from Ronnie. And he also said, “You know, you got to be quiet, because they'll let you know who they are.” And this is my roommate, who is my age, but if you ask him how old he is, he'll always tell you he's nineteen. I said, “Ronnie, how are you going to be nineteen?” He said, “That's when I met Yvonne. So, I stopped aging right there.” So you learned poetic things like that, which you wouldn't, you know, you wouldn't learn from anyone else, but the program itself, if you can keep students talking to each other and having patience with each other, it can be tremendous. It can be just, just so wonderful. And again, remember, this is just one person, you're going to get thirty-seven different stories out there. So this is just—like I say, this is just me. It touched me that much.

MB: 39:59
Right. So on that same note, how do you think your involvement in SAP, EOP—how did that manifest itself in your later life decisions?

MM: 40:20
I made one mistake, I think. I graduated and I was offered a partial scholarship to Columbia University. I didn't take it, that was my mistake. I went to work for Kmart, became an assistant manager, and this is where I learned that you had to—you have to deal with the outside world, because everybody else was White. So I was a novelty as an assistant manager, but it did help me to balance out and also to be as quick with my mind as they were. And also learned, you know, if you're bad at a course, or if there's something you like and you're not good at it, you can fake it, but you can only fake it for a semester. So before—by the time the second semester comes around, you better know some of your stuff, you know, you better—okay, you can fake it because it's introductory and it's introductory, so instead of going to your room to sleep, you better go to your room and pick up a book to help you catch up. You can fake it, but only for a semester. So same thing at work. This is retail—okay, I'm going to fake it, but I have to double time it to catch up so that when the semester—second semester comes around, they know I didn't fake it the first semester. So I learned how to double time it to catch up and that's very necessary that you—I could tell you I'm a doctor at so and so, all you can do is believe me, because you don’t know, but then I better run and get the facts together, I guess, so that the next time when you ask me a question, I'll have a reasonable answer. Or I'll have the answer. So if you—you can fake it for a semester, let them know, but when the time comes to go to—go back to your room, you can't be partying, you can't be sleeping. You got to play catch up. While they’re—while the other folks don't realize you're playing catch up. So it taught me how to walk that tightrope.

MB: 43:05
And in terms of your—like after graduating, do you think it influenced your choice in profession, or community involvement, personal politics?

MM: 43:22
Okay I'm sorry. I don't think I understood that.

MB: 43:24
So after you graduated, do you think your experience in SAP kind of influenced your choices in like profession or your personal politics, like what you carried on through life?

MM: 43:39
Well, as far as my politics, I always try to think of what happened to me, and naturally chose a politician or a party that I felt had my back and my people's back. I tried to more so engage, especially with people I ran into. They always profess one way of thinking, and I always try to say, tell them, “Okay, but look at it this way. Suppose this came up, suppose that came up and how is that affecting you? How is that—“ Because there—this thing came up after I graduated, that we were given help that we didn't deserve. We were—because of our color, because I’m Puerto Rican or, “Well, sure they'll let you in because they have a quota now, because, you know, you really don't deserve it.” So you had to fight that too. And you kind of had to prove yourself that, you know, that they were wrong. You always had—you had to kind of have a chip on your shoulder. And whereas when I was younger, I used to walk down the street, it's funny, I think about it now, but you walk down the street and not look anybody in the eye, and after that, you kind of straighten up, and when somebody talks to you, you look them in the eye, and you kind of take the [inaudible]. That's funny, because that's what I tell my grandson, “You shake somebody's hand, you look them in the eye, you talk to somebody, you look them in the eye, you do something wrong, you take your medicine.” So, oh, that helped me a lot, personally, yeah, and thank god, but I've always had a good sense of humor too. I kind of see things in a weird [laughs] way sometimes, and that has helped me out too.

MB: 46:13
Okay, yeah, and then—so for your profession, do you think that SAP had any influence on that?

MM: 46:20
Well it helped open the door, because a lot of the stuff that you saw, I didn't want to—when I graduated in (19)75 the economy was not good. So you just [inaudible], I know nowadays you just, you type out resumes, but back then you had to print them out, and you had to read them over, and you had to mail them in. So I wound up going to Kmart because they were hiring and you needed the money(??), now, you're not in school anymore, you don't, you know, you better get a job. And you're going to get married, you better get a job. So they were hiring, I lived in a motel room and walked to work up in New Hartford, New York. So I didn't have a car, so I got a motel room near the store. But I was going to be married in October, I had to get a job. So I walked from the hotel—motel room to the store, and every once in a while, the state police would stop me, because what am I doing walking on the road? Plus, I still had my afro at the time. So I have a long coat and an afro, I just fit the profile. So I had to show my ID, and I had to prove to them that I'm walking to work and that I live in this motel room. So I went to work there, and then in August, got married in August, had an apartment that had four rooms, no furniture. So we got married, and when we—me and my wife came back home, the only piece of furniture we had [laughs] was an American tourist(??) of luggage that we used as a kitchen table, and we slept on a mattress on the floor, but we've been together forty-nine years now, but I didn't—my [inaudible] and one of my bigger problems, as I say, is up here, was my self confidence as far as doing things. My wife always said I should have been a teacher. Everybody always says I should have been a teacher. My son-in-law says I should have been a teacher, but I didn't have the confidence to be able to—I didn't want to feel like I was short-changing students. So I still have that in me. I don't want—I want to let you know everything I know, but I don't want to short-change you, and that's always been my problem. But after that, you don't have time to think about, you know, your shortcomings, because you got too many responsibilities. You got a car payment. You're going to have to get—pay the rent. Oh, my daughter's going to be born. Oh, I have to—now your—when your child is born, you don't see a baby, you see an eighteen-year-old that's got to go to college one day, you know. So life takes over in a lot of ways. So that's why I say when you're a student, it's so important to go for your—not for your major, go for your passion, because you've got that one chance, because life is going to come at you, and you won't have that chance to grab your passion. They're very—you may have another chance, but you have very few chances. But when you're a student and you got EOP behind you, you can really do it.

MB: 50:16
Right. So moving on to the present day and what's happening right now. What are your thoughts on the current legislation affecting higher education right now?

MM: 50:34
It's something that I never thought would happen. Like I told you, I went to—I was trying to organize a reunion, and I see from the other classmates, the militant, the old, young militant, coming out again(??) because you don't think you had to fight this battle again, and again you're fighting, and it's worse because it's—they're not—it's good in one sense, because they're coming at you. They're not hiding anything, but it's bad in the other sense, because they've got the power. I see—I get scared because they don't have—there's still a majority, but like, for instance, you're going to—if you're going to try to get rid of eleven million people that are here illegally, eleven million? You can't do that without bloodshed. You can't snatch your child from a mother without the scars being there. And I'm not talking just about for the—I'm talking about for generations to come. You see an older brother see a baby sister or brother being snatched out of his mother's arms. That young thirteen or fourteen, fifteen-year-old is going to be a twenty-five, thirty-five-year-old looking for some payback. And I'm not talking about one person. I'm talking about multiples. There's no time in history where a payback doesn't happen and then there's always the peripheral damage, because they—you know, when a bullet is fired at one person, it doesn't know that, it's going to go to the nearest target. And logic never wins out over emotion until the damage is so terrible you can't take it back. I'm scared for my grandchildren. I'm scared for my children. There's a—I see children—my neighbor's children, she's got four little babies. They're White. I'm scared for them. They're White. They call me Mr. Martin. They wave their little hands at me. Their parents are White, they're from Minnesota. They trust me, that can be totally damaged in an instant, with one person spewing something and people not question—you have to question anything anybody tells you, because you don't know their motives. So I'm more frightened now then I was in the (19)70s, and I'm scared because the young people, they don't believe in history—you know, the Holocaust wasn't that long ago, okay? You think—oh, you think it's that long because you look at it in books or movies and—but it's when(??) a lot—it's with—in people's lifetimes, and when you say—for instance, when you try to erase Jackie Robinson from history, you try to erase it, you have no idea what the damage that puts in the back of your head and it's smoldering, you don't know that, but it's smoldering, and something is going to set it off. That's what scares me. Something is going to set that off. And people—this is then(??)—people are going to have to choose sides. And you know, you think that America is forever. Rome thought it was forever. So it's scary, it's very scary.

MB: 55:38
So I know you mentioned the importance of history and historicizing things—you're a historian [laughs]. So, what do you think SAP, slash EOP, can tell us about American history and society?

MM: 55:59
This—in other countries, it's kind of different. This country, because it's made up of diversity—which is supposed to be its strength—it's turned on its ear and the diversity, for some people, it seems to be like it's danger. EOP is always going to be necessary, because in a capitalistic society, there's always going to be the poor, there's always going to be the under ton(??), they're always going to need a leg up. They don't necessarily all have to be Black, Latin, Oriental, some of these people are going to be, like, from Appalachia, okay, you can draw some people from there. I always felt like you have, you know, foreign exchange students from different countries. I wish—I always felt that I wish we had a—some type of a domestic exchange student. Get a White farmer, child, high schooler from Iowa, put him in the Bronx, okay, for a year, and take a Black kid from the projects, put him in Iowa, okay? Show—we're not that different. We want the same things. The mentality is different, but that'll change also, you get—that's the only way you're going to stop this, this fear of each other, walk is(??)—walk a mile in my shoes, okay? Yeah, exchanging—there was a book called Tally’s Corner, where a White, I think he was a White—the writer went in and he lived in the ghettos, and you kind of—it's funny, but you see what they think, how they think, why they think that way. You kind of—I always enjoyed Black humor, but I had my mom, I enjoyed Puerto Rican humor. Every little bit of humor is a little bit different, but you learn to appreciate the humor. Learn to appreciate the dancing. Learn to appreciate the food. Okay, you need to kind of shuffle the deck. You have to get the black heart and the black—and the ace of spades and just mix it, mix it up. That's the only thing that's—that the EOP can do, because it's not only Blacks and Latins, but there's going to be some people from Appalachia that going to—and then they'll see, “Hey, you know something I like—I don't like grits but, you know, maybe I can like them, let me see what they taste like. Let me see, you know—“ You have to have that exchange. Look at me—look at me and Ronnie, we walked into a room and we say that the biggest blessing we had was that we walked into that room color-blind. Okay, we walked in—and he didn't judge me and I didn't judge him and and we just learned from each other. That's how EOP can help. Okay? Let the EOP director counsel some White students and let the White students see that, “Hey, this Black director, you know, she kind of knows what she's talking about. You know, she's here to help me, not to, you know, to show me the—how Black people have—how White people have enslaved Black people all the time. She's here to help me.” You have to get that mixture in there. Otherwise, the diversity, instead of being the strength, is always going to be seen somehow, as, Oh they're getting over on me, this one's getting over on me. That's the way I see it. And unfortunately, that's something that would take a long time.

MB: 1:00:21
Right, right. So would you do anything differently if you were able to go back to when you were a student at Binghamton?

MM: 1:00:36
Differently. I would be more involved in, probably LASU, because I think that although their opinions count, my opinions count too, whereas I didn't see it that way before. I would like to take some students and let them realize that, you know something, when I was growing up, just as an example, when they showed a Black person on a TV commercial—I was at my friend's house, and all of a sudden you'd hear “Colored on TV! Colored on TV!” Because you never saw a Black person on a commercial, and now you see mixed groups, mixed couples, you know, so in—if you saw a Black in a commercial, he was probably carrying—he was a red cap, or he was carrying somebody's bag. But now to see him just in a TV commercial, you have TV shows that all of the cast members are Black. Are you kidding me? Are you kidding me? When I—one of my favorite shows was The Danny Thomas Show, they had one Black cast member, and who was she? She was the maid! And the change is incredible, but it's also incredible how that deep civil war mentality is in there. You know? I mean, I don't see—I remember Sidney Poitier when he when he won the Academy Award, he said, “Stop seeing me—“, and I'm paraphrasing, “—well, why can't you see me as an actor and stop seeing me as a Black actor.” So yeah, I would kind of mix the—mix the classroom up. Also show Black students who were used to seeing Black shows, Black TV commercials, you know, stars on TV, show them how much has changed, and then have a White student also come in and show them same TV commercial and say, “Do you know that this is history. This never happened before. Do you know that you—they used to show commercial on Afro Sheen, you know they never had any hair products for Blacks when I was growing up on TV(??).” Hey, black and white TV, it was just white TV. The change that is there and the change that can be. They had—Petula Clark, she touched Harry Belafonte’s arm singing a song once, and they banned showing that song in the South because she touched his arm. Do you know the change that has happened? But you have to wash—get that brainwashing out of your head and give each other some credit, each other some credit, and know that every opinion counts. As silly as it might sound, you know? How ridiculous is that—it might be, but it was my opinion, and that's the way I felt. So I think I'd shuffle the deck a little bit.

MB: 1:04:25
Okay, so is there anything else that you wanted to talk about that we didn't already discuss?

MM: 1:04:32
No, I wish—I always had a wish to come back and talk to the students that are there now. But not as a way—it's funny—it's not as a way of talking to the students. I’d like to go back up there and talk to myself. So as I'm talking, I'm telling my story. It's not for everyone, but I might touch that one person. I might touch that one person and let them know, go for your passion. You have to go for your passion, because you don't want to all of a sudden wind up saying, you know something, I'm good at this, but I love that. You can always survive, you can always—you can go out there and sell hot peanuts and survive. Okay, you have to go for your passion. That's—that was me, anyway.

MB: 1:05:31
Is there any other advice that you would give to current EOP students?

MM: 1:05:38
I was there two years ago, and it was mind blowing, because when I was there, the College-in-the-Woods was brand new. That sucker is fifty years old now, and it's just—it's mind blowing. I mean, I wish there was a way to kind of let them have the feeling that I had, but again, it's totally—in a way, it's different, and in a way it's not. Because when I was there two years ago, they had a—BSU, had a fashion show, and I was just in the Student Union. And if I closed my eyes and just listen to the noise, it sounded just like I was there fifty years ago. And that was pretty nice, that was great.

MB: 1:06:33
Yeah.

MM: 1:06:35
So I would love to bring a bunch of us back, and I would love to have each of us sit at different tables, and for the students to find the one they must relate to and speak with that person. I would like to find me, whether it's a girl, whether it's a [inaudible]—whoever—find me, listen to me and want to talk to me because they feel a kinship to me. That's what I would want to do, I'd like to find me.

MB: 1:07:12
All right, okay, so I think that's the end of our interview. Thank you so much for your time and for sharing your experience and like your thoughts.

MM: 1:07:25
Thank you. I don't think it was important. I don't think—I think I might actually be anti-climactic as you go along, but I appreciate the opportunity to kind of spew and open my mouth. Thank you so much.

MB: 1:07:38
Of course, yeah.

[End of interview]

Files

Item Information

Citation

Montalvo, Martin, “Oral Interview with Martin Montalvo,” Digital Collections, accessed November 17, 2026, https://omeka.binghamton.edu/omeka/items/show/3353.