Skip to main content
Libraries

Oral Interview with The Honorable Theodore McKee

:: ::

Title

Oral Interview with The Honorable Theodore McKee

Creator

Mckee, Theodore

Contributor

Burbano, Mariapaz

Subject

Binghamton University; Educational Opportunity Program; Special Admissions Program

Description

Theodore McKee was a graduate of the State University of New York at Cortland and became a recruiter for the Educational Opportunity Program during the early years of the program in the late 1960s. Afterwards, he went to law school and became an attorney and served as a federal judge for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. At the time of the interview he was a judge with senior status. In this interview with McKee, he discusses his background and what motivated him to work with EOP, highlighting the impact of the 1960s Civil Rights Movement and societal disparities on his decision. He details his role as a recruiter and the unique, holistic admissions approach he employed, including recruiting students directly from prison, and reflects on the challenges and tensions faced by EOP students on campus during a tumultuous historical period. Finally, McKee offers his perspective on current issues in higher education, such as the repeal of affirmative action and attacks on diversity, expressing concern about a retreat from efforts to broaden opportunity and emphasizing the importance of academic rigor for current EOP students.

Identifier

TMcKee.mp4

Date Created

2024-12-06

Date Modified

2024-12-06

License

Copyright held by the State University at Binghamton

Is Part Of

Educational Opportunity Program at Binghamton University records

Extent

43:46:00

Medium

mp4

Transcription

[Start of interview]

MB: 00:01
Okay, all right. Well, today's date is December 6, 2024. My name is Mariapaz Burbano, and I am a graduate student at Binghamton University pursuing my Master's degree in human rights. I am interviewing Theodore McKee using the virtual meeting platform Zoom. The purpose of this interview is to talk about the early history of programs that provided broader access to higher education at Binghamton University, namely, the Educational Opportunity Program and related programs. Ted, could you please say and spell your full name and indicate your verbal consent to be recorded for this project.

TM: 00:43
Yeah, I do consent to the recording. The full name is Theodore McKee, M, C, K, E, E, Theodore T, H, E, O, D, O, R, E, but I go by the name of Ted.

MB: 00:53
Alright, thank you. Okay, so to begin, I kind of wanted to start a little bit more general and just get a sense of your background. So my first question is, what life experiences led you to work in Special Admissions and EOP?

TM: 01:13
Well that is an excellent question. I think it was just a sensitivity that developed around the events of the (19)60s about the disparities in society—in education, certainly—but generally throughout society, and the need to want to try to do something to mitigate some of the disparities in society.

MB: 01:36
So kind of going all the way back to your childhood and the location where you grew up, your neighborhood, your immediate family, and their opinions or experiences in anything like academia or their occupation. Would you want to talk about some of that?

TM: 02:00
Yeah, well, I grew up [inaudible] a small town in upstate New York, outside of Rochester town called Scottsville, population of less than 4000 very rural with not even a bedroom community of Rochester. It was more just a small rural community, not really a farming community. My dad was waiter in the railroad, New York Central. Pretty much all my life that he was, until he retired, he was a waiter, waiter in charge on the railroad. My mom worked in the kitchen at the school that I attended, and did housekeeping work as a domestic worker for some of the people in town. My grandmother lived with us. My grandmother did—she was retired. She lived to be 94, 95 but she also was like of a live-in maid for one of the people in the town, actually, at the end of the street where our house was. One brother who's about four or five years older than me, also a lawyer but he is not practicing law now. And the town, sure it was almost all White. There were four families, four Black families in the town, including ours. The only real diversity came in the fall of every year, when migrant workers from Florida came through to help with the harvest of beans and potatoes, they would come in September, and they would stay through the first frost. We called them the “camps” because they stayed in a small camp in a hamlet called Garbutt, maybe seven or eight miles outside of Scottsville. And my senior year, especially, I became friendly with a number of them, but my earlier years in high school, there was—I did not really know them that well, and there was some distance. Their background was so different than mine, their experiences are different than mine. But as a senior in high school, and I think as a junior, also, my awareness of what I had in common with them became more apparent, and I made it a point to seek them out and become friendly with them and spend some time with them.

MB: 04:05
So how do you think that your childhood and your environment eventually led you to work at Binghamton in Special Admissions?

TM: 04:21
Yeah, I am not sure it did, other than again, the events of the (19)60s, and being sensitized to the disparities of opportunities in society that wasn't so much a result of my childhood as it was national events and all that was going on in the (19)60s—Vietnam, the Civil Rights Movement, and being exposed to that through news media, on television especially, sensitized me to a lot of those things. Also, I was very active in campus politics when I was in college, I got involved with student government, with the National Student Association, and I was chairman of the [technical difficulties, audio cut out]—of folks involved in the Civil Rights Movement, including Muhammad Ali, Dick Gregory, James Forman, Allen Ginsberg, come to mind, Timothy Leary, and Roy Innis, who was then head of CORE. And that certainly—and Stokely Carmichael—and that really made a difference in terms of my perspective and my sensitivity and my wanting to get involved in things.

MB: 05:35
So where—where did you go to college, actually?

TM: 05:39
Cortland State, just north of Binghamton, SUNY Cortland.

MB: 05:44
So after college, would you—could you elaborate a little bit on, you know, what you did post grad?

TM: 05:52
Actually, after college I came to Binghamton, that was my first job upon graduation.

MB: 05:57
Oh [crosstalk].

TM: 05:58
And the only job I had before I went to law school was at SUNY Binghamton, those three years. And it was a great job, it was a dream job for me, and I just upon graduation—I think a few weeks after that—I moved to Binghamton to begin working with the EOP program and John Benson.

MB: 06:19
So what—could you please describe what your role was in EOP—firstly, actually, why did John Benson—so, how did you get hired? How did you get scouted for the role, and what were some of the responsibilities that you had, what were some of the, I guess, obstacles that you faced within your role?

TM: 06:52
Yeah, it was a really fortuitous, serendipitous way I got hired, because, as I said, I was very active in student government at Cortland. I was at a number of meetings with administrators for the state and Western New York, one of whom was a guy named Doctor Smoot. I cannot remember his first name now, but Smoot was, I think, the Vice Chancellor of the SUNY system—Black—and I didn't get to know him well, but at the time, there were so few Black students that were SUNY students, he immediately recognized me and we gravitated toward one another. And he asked me one time during a chance encounter what I was going to do upon graduation. I told him I did not know. He asked me to give him his resume. He said he would circulate it for me. So I did, I gave it to him. He sent it out to a number of SUNY schools, including Binghamton. John got it and John responded, John was the only one who responded about an opportunity to work at Binghamton in the capacity of a recruiter for the Special Admissions Program, as it was then known, that John was developing. And I met with John and got hired for that, and that is how that came to be.

MB: 08:09
So, after getting hired, did you—so how was the experience? You know, I guess—

TM: 08:18
It was phenomenal. It was a dream job, it was phenomenal. John became one of, if not my best friend in life throughout the years. And working with John was—it was a joy getting out of bed and going in, because I got—he was just a great guy, and he was doing such meaningful things, such creative and original things. In retrospect, I am amazed what he was able to pull off at SUNY, especially given the dynamics and the bureaucracy at SUNY, it was really astonishing. And I think he made a meaningful—I know he made a meaningful change that had a meaningful impact on not just SUNY at Binghamton, but on the lives of the people who were brought into the program while he was there. My job was a recruiter, I guess technically, I was in charge of admissions for the Special Admissions Program, but it was really broader than that. John had an understanding with me that in my travels throughout the state recruiting students, if I ran into students who wanted something that really was not a good fit for Binghamton that [inaudible] refer them to other campuses throughout the state system. And I did that not frequently, because I didn't have that breadth of knowledge. There is so many programs available at the [inaudible] of New York. But for example, if I were to run into somebody who wanted to go to school to get a degree in physical education, I would have referred them to either Brockport State or Cortland State, not SUNY Binghamton, because SUNY Binghamton was not offering those kinds of courses. There were programs at the two year school that I am blocking on now that I would eventually sometimes refer people to if they were interested in more artistic kinds of things and—but 99 percent of it was focusing on just getting the students recruited to Binghamton. I had sole admissions authority, which was another amazing [inaudible] pulled off. My office was in the Office of Admissions at Binghamton, but I did not report to the Director of Admissions who was [inaudible]. I reported to John Benson, and as I said, it has sole authority for who was admitted into the special admissions program. Also, there was some work with graduate students, not a lot, but I did get involved to some extent, with trying to recruit minority, primarily black and Latino graduate students to the university, and that was primarily at Jackson State, and made a couple of visits to Jackson. There was one student, I cannot remember his name now, but I think it was only one or two that I was involved with, getting them recruited to come to the sunny Binghamton but that did happen.

MB: 11:02
So do you recall any—I know you said that it was an amazing experience, but do you recall any times when you felt like the position definitely involved overcoming some obstacles, especially considering the historical time that this was set in?

TM: 11:24
Yeah, John was very good, but I knew that he was fighting a lot of battles and overcoming a lot of obstacles, but he basically plowed the path for me, so all I had to do is do my job, and I didn't have to really deal—with one exception—I didn't really have to deal with any kind of bureaucratic encounters at the university. John really handled all of those and was very good about sheltering all of the administrators in the program from those kinds of concerns and taking it upon him himself.

MB: 11:54
So kind of moving on from EOP, how did your involvement in EOP manifest itself in your later life decisions? So this includes your profession, your cultural relations, community involvement, or personal politics, even.

TM: 12:15
I would have to think about that. I am not sure—other than being an extension of my personal politics—I am not sure that it manifested itself in any other way. I thought while I was there that I was doing something to basically advance the common good, and by that, I mean doing something to work against the inequalities in society by getting really talented people into a college—a good college program—who would not otherwise get into the program, because I was really trying to employ a holistic approach, not just look at—certainly not SAT scores, but focusing on recommendations, very heavily on recommendations, on my own assessment of the person's maturity and intellectual ability, and using that as a level to admit them to the university. While doing that, I got involved with—and I am not quite sure what—I know what motivated this, but I am not quite sure how I initiated it, but I did recruit a number of people from prison into the university, some of whom were incredible success stories, and some of whom were—didn't do very well. In retrospect, we didn't really have the kind of support systems in place that we should have had for that kind of undertaking. At the time, I was incredibly naive, and I thought if we just got really smart, talented people onto the campus that things would take care of themselves. Not a lot of support, not any support, really. Despite that, a couple of the students especially did incredibly well. One Louis del Valle, Louis went on, I think, to become director of the program for a while. Got a Master's degree and was absolutely beloved by the students on campus. Another Ron Benjamin, who's still practicing law in Binghamton, New York. And there were some other folks that were involved—I think, and I tried to remember the numbers, I cannot remember the exact numbers. I am guessing it was maybe 10 or so students during the three years that were recruited to the university directly from prison. When I say directly from prison, I mean directly from prison. A couple of guys got off the bus, and they are in the prison-issued clothes, had no place to stay, and John and I worked that out so they would have a place to stay, usually Colonial Motor Inn. And that is what I mean, when we didn't really have a good sense of what we were into, because there should have been a lot more support in place for those folks because of the incredible adjustment they had to make. To their credit, some of them were able to make that adjustment and complete their very demanding academic program and succeed at Binghamton.

MB: 14:57
So could you describe—I know we talked a little bit about, you know, how tumultuous that time period was, but could you further describe the historical events that were occurring at that time?

TM: 15:12
Yeah, well, it was Vietnam certainly occurring at that time, it was—the Vietnam War was in full heights. I remember when I was there was during the time of the so called Cambodian Incursion, when Nixon ordered an invasion of Cambodia, and that precipitated demonstrations on campus, not just at Binghamton, but nationally. As I recall, the then president [inaudible] at lunchtime, would read the names of the soldiers who had been killed the day before in the quad. It was very emotional a time. There were takeovers of buildings, not at Binghamton, but certainly Columbia, Berkeley, Cornell was a very notable one just down the street, where students took over administration buildings, demanding in many times, African American Studies programs. And I think that was the crux of most of the takeovers, was demanding African American Studies programs. The free speech movement at Berkeley, where students were demanding more access to just speech, more freedom of speech. And that was also a big part of the upheaval at Columbia. There were demonstrations in the cities. It was shortly after the assassinations of Martin Luther King—was several years after Kennedy, John Kennedy, so that wasn't that much a part of it, but King's assassination, Malcolm X's assassination, it was an incredibly—I want to say, brutal is probably not the right word, but it may be the right word, but in terms of public events, it was a very, very dynamic—and not always in a positive sense—time, and the students were caught up in that. I mean, these were students who had social consciousness, which was one of the things I was looking for when I recruited them to the university. I was looking for students who would be committed to their communities when they graduated, go out and make a difference in the world, and not just try to get a high paying job. So we had students there that were very politically aware, culturally aware, on a campus that was not that in-tuned with Black or Latino culture, and that created for a lot of tension, a lot of conflict, but in a very positive way, because it—I think, was part of the educational experience for everybody. It exposed White students who wouldn't otherwise have been exposed to that dynamic, to Black and Latino students, Black and Latino culture. It exposed Black and Latino students to a segment and a cohort of students that they otherwise would not have come in contact with growing up in the neighborhoods that they grew up in. And it was educationally, it was an incredibly dynamic time.

MB: 18:00
Thank you for that. So I know you mentioned the—how students were interacting with groups that they previously might not have before. Could you—what did you perceive about the environment at Binghamton University's campus, specifically regarding—

TM: 18:19
[Cross talk] Intense.

MB: 18:20
—student groups? Yeah.

TM: 18:21
Yeah. It was very, very tense. A lot of hostility. There were a lot of White students and administrators who didn't think that the Black students and Latino students belonged there, that we were ruining the prestige of the university. There was a lot of that. John got a lot more of that than I did, but I caught some of the ethos of it, if you will. Our students felt it very much. They were aware of the fact that a lot of their White cohort peers did not think that they belonged there, and I know that put even more pressure on them to succeed. It is the old thing of collective failure and individual success that when Black and Latino students fail it is looked at as a collective failure and endemic of the group. But when the success—a success, the reaction oftentimes is, “Oh, well, he is different. He is not like the others,” especially the individual success. So there was a lot of that nonsense going on that just added to the pressure that students had to deal with.

MB: 19:19
Right, yeah. So do you think that the overall attitude towards the program during this period was positive, negative, somewhere in the middle?

TM: 19:31
I think in the middle, you know, and it varied from administrator to administrator, students to students. We had some students who were just absolute standouts, and they did so well that people couldn't sit back and say that these people didn't belong there, because we had students who were drawing straight A's, but we had a lot of students who were really struggling, really struggling. And the challenge for John was to get to the point where the folks who were really struggling were not used by the university to tank and undermine the program. And fortunately that there were a lot of very supportive White administrators, senior administrators and faculty there who were real allies, who believed in what we are trying to do, who went to bat for us. Saw the worth of the program, the worth of the students we are bringing in, and that made all the difference in the world. Without some of the support we had from White administrators and faculty we couldn't pull this off—I say we, John couldn’t have pulled it off. I didn't pull it off. John is the one who pulled this off.

MB: 19:41
So do you think that the institutional culture of the university affected the success of the program and the students?

TM: 20:46
I think it is probably the other way around. I think the students being there and what they lent to campus affected the intellectual and institutional success of the university, and the university was much better off because of the program, because of these students being there. I believe that very, very strongly.

MB: 21:07
So going back a little bit to a point that you mentioned about the students, you know, getting to know a different environment in general, so I am sure the adaptation was a little turbulent [laughs].

TM: 21:25
[Laughs] Yeah, yeah, it was.

MB: 21:26
Do you remember—do you remember if there were any students’ reactions that stood out to you as they were adapting to the program and university life?

TM: 21:34
Well, I remember there was this one time a couple White students came to me and complained about the Black students who were wandering around in “packs”, and that was the term that they used. They were roaming around in packs, and this student was complaining about the fact that the Black students were traveling together on campus. And when I asked her what she meant, she said, “Well, yeah that they are roaming around in the packs of them, and they are roaming around campus.” And by packs, she meant two or three students were walking together from place A to place B. And you know, there was a manifestation of a lot of the ignorance and racism that was there, that was—the students had to deal with that made it much more difficult for them to succeed on campus, but as I said, many of them did, to their credit, I do not remember any specific instances beyond that one instance where the students—White students—came to me complaining about the packs of Black students who were roaming around. In the athletic programs there was a lot of tension. There was a very active intramural program there, and there was a basketball team called the Giants, and there was also a flag football team, a touch football team, I think, also called the Giants. And especially on the basketball court, there was a lot of tension between the Black team playing some of the White teams. I think a couple of physical alterations that broke out, and we got through all that stuff, and actually one of the students in the program went on become a very successful college, I think a junior college coach, and I think in North Carolina or in Tennessee.

MB: 23:16
So, I am sorry for circling back [laughs] so many times, but do you mind expanding a little bit more on the—I know you mentioned that you scouted some students, or potential students, from prison, straight out of prison. So could you maybe describe how that process went, and how did those students’ experiences differ from the traditional EOP students?

TM: 23:47
Yeah, and I've tried to think how that got up and got on the way, and I cannot recall—I remember what motivated me to do it, was the belief I've always had that because of the dynamics and the pressures of inner city life, some very intelligent people end up getting sucked into the criminal justice system, and I continue to see that today in some stuff that I am involved in. So I thought, well, it may be a fertile ground recruit people into college from prisons, but I do not remember now how I made the contract, because, as you can imagine, you cannot just walk into prison and start handing out literature. But I guess the word got out [inaudible], particularly in Green Haven State Prison, word got out, and I would get letters from inmates. And I cannot remember what the process was—I know they had to fill out an application. I remember one essay—this was by Louis, who I admitted, who, as I said, went on to become head of the program and got his Master's degree—I remember reading Louis’s essay, and was so incredibly poignant. It showed a really profound thought process and intellect. And I knew that this guy could do college work. He was older, and he experienced a number of problems because of the adjustments he had to go through having spent time in prison, some drug addiction—I do not think mind my sharing that—but he succeeded. Generally, though, the process was, as I said before, the person would just be admitted to come to the university and start taking classes, which was a problem on our part [inaudible] that is not the way to do what we were doing. We didn't know any better at the time, and somehow people managed to survive it. But as I think back on it, and I want to shutter it, the naivete that we had in thinking that that was a good approach to the problem, I am glad we did it, but I wish I could go back and do it differently, because I think we’d have a higher level of success if we did it today, if I were to go back knowing what I know now, it would be done very differently.

MB: 25:50
And do you remember if there—if those students adapted to the program a little bit differently, or did they kind of like—yeah.

TM: 26:03
Yeah, some did. They struggled because they would have to not just go to class, but they had to report to their probation officer. And I remember one student, especially, who was very, very successful, ended up developing a program I cannot [inaudible], I think, was called Pride, I am not sure of that, but while he was in the university, he developed a program to help people who are on supervision by the criminal justice system—Probe was name of the organization—he would be walking around campus in a three-piece suit, because you have to meet with people for funding. He would meet his probation officer and he would go to class. He was—I do not know how he did it, he was very successful. Graduated in three years, I believe, too, [inaudible] to the University of Buffalo Law School, and is now an incredibly successful attorney in Binghamton. But for most of the students, that was just dealing with getting from point A to point B, getting to class, doing the work, and then adjusting to being out in the incredible amount of freedom that you have on a college campus, as opposed to the total absence of freedom that you have in a prison situation, and trying to adjust to that. Some students could not do that. There is one student, especially, I remember, who ended up—big disappointment—ended up dealing heroin. I do not know if it was heroin but he was dealing drugs, but that was the only guy that I know of who came in who ended up resorting to criminal conduct while I was on campus. There was another guy who was a very accomplished musician, and I do not think he graduated. He died a few years ago in D.C., and there is now a scholarship in the city of D.C. in his name to try to get jazz into the high schools in Washington. And I consider him a success, even though he may not have graduated, his life was totally changed and became a very productive member of society, and I think the experience he had at Binghamton really helped him contribute when he went to D.C. and began living there with his wife.

MB: 28:03
Okay, so kind of moving on into the present day. I am very interested in hearing your thoughts on current legislation affecting higher education, especially with your background as an attorney and a judge.

TM: 28:20
Well actually, I was just reading today about cutbacks at Michigan in their diversity training. And it is—there is been a retrenchment, which is incredibly unfortunate. I do not know how long it is going to last, but it is, it is going to work to the detriment of the society. This—I call it legislating stupid. I mean, there are states where there are proposals, as you know, against teaching kids subject matter that will make them feel uncomfortable, whatever the hell that means. I do not know how you can teach anybody's history without making them feel—the students feel uncomfortable, because that is kind of what history is. It is not just the good stuff you did, it is the bad stuff, and given what happened in this country, with the institution of slavery, which remnants of which are still with us. What happened with the Native Americans, what happened to the Japanese, so called internment camps in World War II, Chinese immigration. You cannot teach that history without students feeling uncomfortable. If they do not feel uncomfortable, there is something wrong with the student. There is something wrong with the way you are teaching it. And so we are into an era where it seems to be fashionable to be okay with stupid, and that is troublesome because you cannot fix the problems of a society if you cannot identify the problems or the roots of the problem, if you are not aware of the history, you cannot possibly be aware of the root of the problem. So I am really pessimistic about that, and I do not know if it is going to change or not. I think we are heading in the wrong direction now, and what we need to do is what was being advocated for by students and many administrators in the (19)60s, and that is education. It really is education that teaches people, not just Black and Latino history, but true history. If you teach true history, you get the Black and Latino history because you cannot teach American history without teaching Black history. And slavery generated the funds with which the American Revolution was fought, but that is not something which is generally recognized, that the wealth of the country was produced through the institution of slavery, [inaudible] on the backs of slaves. But if we do not know that, I do not know how we can fix the problems that we have now, and I do not think we are trying to fix them now, we are trying to run from them and sweep them under the rug, which makes people feel more comfortable for a while, but sooner or later, that is going to rear its head and bite us in the butt, I am afraid.

MB: 30:42
Right, yeah. Kind of like along that same line, how do you feel about the repeal of affirmative action?

TM: 30:53
It is ridiculous. It is absolutely ridiculous. And a lot has been said about this, but you know, we still have legacy preferences, you have athletic preferences. The only way you can really maximize a society's potential is to make sure that people are able to achieve their fullest potential. If you have a society where people who can afford to take SAT prep courses can increase their SAT scores by 50 or 75 points and then apply to institutions that are going to make admissions decisions based upon SAT scores, what they are doing is they are making an SAT decision based upon the wealth of the family that the student is from and the opportunities afforded in that particular community, not judging the potential of that individual student. So it means a lot of really talented people are being cast by the wayside, and that is to the detriment of the entire society, it is that old adage that a mind is a terrible thing to waste. It is really self-defeating, what is going on right now. I do not know how long it is going to last, but the longer it lasts, the weaker the society is going to be, and the more ignorant it is going to be.

MB: 32:01
Right. How do you feel about—I know you mentioned that you think we are not going in the right direction as a country, but could you elaborate a little bit more on that?

TM: 32:12
Yeah, it is kind of fear of reality, and it is finding comfort in ignorance and stupidity, and lack of information. Well, the last—most recent example, the transgender case that was argued in front of the Supreme Court earlier this week, challenges to the states—and a number of them—that have laws that prevent the doctors from doing what the doctors and the parents feel the need to do to give kids who are experiencing some kind of identity issues with their sexual identity, to help them if they want to become a trans student and change their sex or adapt to a sex that they feel is really the sex, not the one they were assigned at birth. That is an incredibly complicated question. It has absolutely no business being decided by politicians, especially politicians who are more interested in applying to the public for sound bites, or appealing for sound bites and political contributions. And it certainly doesn't belong in the hands of judges who are not doctors. That belongs—it should be decided by physicians and parents, and we have statutes that preclude that happening. That is a real problem. And it is not just there, there are other areas too. The whole abortion area, you know, doctors and moms need to make those decisions, not politicians who are parading for their public or judges. It is the whole idea of when life begins that can be debated forever. It has been debated forever. What is the nature of life? That is a philosophical question, it is not a legal question, and it shouldn't be decided in the courts. So for judges to try to decide whether or not life begins at conception—really, I mean, we could also try to decide how many angels can dance on the head of a pin, we have as much success with one inquiry as we would with the other. It is just—it is an inherently personal, philosophical, religious question that has no business being decided by politicians whose best—whose interest is usually their own self-interest in getting reelected and generating campaign funds, as opposed to the health of the mom and certainly not judges who are not physicians.

MB: 34:39
Yeah, and I—so I think kind of like the same idea of manipulation of—you know, for a political gain, along the same lines. Do you think that higher education will look very different? Maybe 10, 20, 50, years from now, and do you think it'll be for the better or for the worse?

TM: 35:08
Yeah, I hope it looks different. I hope it is for the better, but, you know, I just do not know. I do not see anything right now that suggests that this is going to turn around. I had a discussion with a friend who's actually a graduate of the program at Binghamton. She is a historian, and she reminds me that the pendulum swings in both directions, that there'll be movement in one direction, then it will stop, and there will be movement in the other direction. And it is kind of a historical process. And maybe she is right, maybe what we are going through now is—has historical analogs where there is been push back, and it has historically been pushed back to gains that have been made by disenfranchised groups, but that push back comes to an end, and it is the old thing about the arc, our freedom is long, but it bends toward freedom—I am misquoting that, but you know what I mean? I am not sure that is true, but I hope it is, but I do not know in 50 years if it is going to look more oppressive and more restrictive, or if we are going to get back to the path we had been on where we try to allow each person to reach their own potential divorce from the chains of discrimination. And I just do not know, I am not optimistic.

MB: 36:20
How do you—how do you feel about EOP as it is now?

TM: 36:23
Well, I am not quite sure where it is right now. I know when I was there last, it seemed like the program had changed drastically, and that the students, from what I could tell, the students who are being admitted in the EOP program, were not the same kind of students that John and I were trying to recruit. We were trying to recruit students who, but for the lens of a holistic approach in the admissions process, would not have gotten into the university. People who were really talented, but that talent manifested itself in ways that traditional screening programs ignored. I get the feeling that a lot of the students who are there now are students who are more consistent with traditional criteria for measuring success in college. I can be wrong about that, but if that is true, that is unfortunate, because then the EOP program just becomes an extension of the admissions office, which is just not what it was set up to be, and it means that there is students out there, very promising students, who will not be given the opportunity because there is only a limited number of slots at the university that they are being taken up by the so called low hanging fruit, the safe bets academically, then you are missing all the Louis del Valle’s of the world. I use Louis as an example, Louis is deceased now, unfortunately, but he is an example of the kind of student I am referring to, incredibly bright, very, very talented, has so much to give to his community, but who would have been ignored and passed over if he was just left to the traditional kinds of admissions criteria, he would have been rejected just because he came out of prison for one thing.

MB: 37:44
Right, yeah. So what do you think that EOP can tell us about American history and society?

TM: 38:10
That we are losing a lot of talented people, and that we need to do something to broaden the opportunities and start living in a manner which is more consistent with the creed that we preach. I guess the best way to say it is that we need to wake up and start being the country that we say we are and not—and stop being the country that I think is very hypocritical, that the disconnect between what we say we are and who we are is widening, and we need to do something about that disconnect. And we really need to—if we are going to be a land of opportunity, that opportunity has to be extended to people who can take advantage of it, and I do not think that is happening as much now as it has in the past.

MB: 38:57
Have you ever thought about what you would do differently if you were suddenly to go back to work in EOP?

TM: 39:08
Wow, if I could go back with John? Yeah, I think we would just—well, the prison example is one example. We would build in more support for the people that would enlarge the program number one, but build in support. And that wouldn't be that hard to do, because the resources are out there, so that the students who are coming in have more supportive services when they come in and they are not just dropped in the middle of a college campus and told, “Okay, now you can sink or swim.” That was just not the way to do that. And as I said, some students survived it, and they actually thrived, but they thrived despite our efforts, not because of our efforts, because we didn't really know what we were doing. That is one thing I would definitely change. And I guess I would try to develop more—kind of a [inaudible], or recruiting mechanism from impoverished areas, areas that we could recruit from, because there are people working in places like settlement houses and rec centers who know the students who are in there, who can recognize talent. And that is a large part of my network for recruiting, was dealing with these kinds of people and getting names of students and then talking to that student. In some cases, a couple of them that [inaudible], hadn't even thought about going to college, they kind of put it off because they didn't think that was a realistic possibility for them, and they had to be persuaded to apply. And one of them was actually just [inaudible], did incredibly well. In fact, several of them did incredibly well, and I would do more on that front to try to recruit people who are going to just lay fallow or be cast aside because of their circumstances.

MB: 40:55
And on the flip side, if you were to work in EOP now, what do you think that some of your—some of the policies that you would kind of push for would be?

TM: 41:08
Yeah, try to get back to where we had been and not admit the low hanging fruit, and that may be an unfair assessment, but I get the feeling that is what is happening now. But go back to trying to identify people. It is a much higher risk, much higher risk category of folk, because the folks that have not demonstrated the kind of academic success in the past that suggests, on some metrics, that they are more likely to succeed in college. But if you can identify those folks, through whatever means, through personal references, getting to know them, by looking at the kinds of obstacles they have overcome, you get an incredibly talented, committed group of folks who can really make a difference in their communities.

MB: 41:53
So before we conclude, is there anything else that you wanted to talk about that we didn't already discuss?

TM: 42:01
Not that I can think of. I am sure that once I step away, I am sure, you know, some things will come to mind, but I cannot think of anything. I am glad the program is still going on and thriving. I do not want anything I say to take away from the fact that it is a credit to the university and the people who are there, that it is still going on and thriving, and it is huge now, compared to the numbers that John and I were dealing with, it is really huge, and that is really good to see.

MB: 42:25
Yeah [chuckles], so for my last question, would you give any advice to current EOP students?

TM: 42:34
Just really strive for excellence. I had a mentor who was somewhat involved with EOP at Cortland, and he came down to Binghamton as kind of a consultant, and his—one of his favorite words was academic rigor. And I really think that students just have to work as hard as they can, do as well as they can successfully to develop options for themselves and to also fortify the program, because every student who really succeeds and thrives, strengthens the program exponentially, and they also create more options and opportunities for themselves by doing that, and hopefully the opportunities will be out there when they graduate, but that would be it. Just do the best you can in school, work incredibly hard, and get the best grades you can possibly get. Grades are not everything, but they are important, and I would really stress academic rigor, as my mentor would have said.

MB: 43:30
All right, okay. So that concludes our interview, thank you so much for taking the time to share your experiences and your thoughts. We really appreciate it [chuckles].

TM: 43:42
Thank you and good luck with this, good luck with this project.

MB: 43:45
Thank you.

[End of interview]

Files

Item Information

Citation

Mckee, Theodore, “Oral Interview with The Honorable Theodore McKee,” Digital Collections, accessed November 17, 2026, https://omeka.binghamton.edu/omeka/items/show/3356.